Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Hotel Premier 14" Hybrid Mattress (Available in Medium, Plush, and Firm) for
Member's Mark Hotel Premier 14" Hybrid Mattress (Available in Medium, Plush, and Firm)
4.1 out of 5 stars
stars
291 ratings194 reviews
  1. 5 stars66% (191)
  2. 4 stars11% (31)
  3. 3 stars7% (21)
  4. 2 stars4% (13)
  5. 1 star12% (35)

Member photos

  • +115 images
Sort by |
Showing 61-70 of 194 reviews
Mar 2, 2026
Joe
1 out of 5 stars review

"Hotel Premier" Experience… If That Hotel Is a Ha

Where do I even begin with the Member's Mark Hotel Premier 14" Hybrid Mattress? Let me start by saying the word "Premier" is doing some very heavy lifting in that product name — unlike the mattress itself, which can't even support a small child without swallowing them whole like some kind of foam-padded Venus flytrap. I've slept on air mattresses at 2 a.m. after Thanksgiving dinner that offered more structural integrity than this thing. Calling it a "hybrid" is generous — it's a hybrid of disappointment and regret. Fourteen inches of mattress and somehow every single one of them is useless. My kid sits on it and practically disappears into the abyss like it's a memory foam black hole. The only thing this mattress is firm enough to support is my growing resentment toward Sam's Club. Speaking of which — let's talk about that famous "Satisfaction Guarantee." You know, the one proudly plastered across their website and membership materials? Turns out it comes with a silent asterisk that reads: unless it's this mattress, in which case, good luck and may God have mercy on your spine. I tried to return it and was met with more resistance than the mattress has ever provided my back. Apparently "100% Satisfaction Guarantee" is more of a vibe than an actual policy. So here I am, stuck with a $400 slab of lies, sleeping like I'm suspended over a pit of marshmallows, wondering what I did to deserve this. If you're looking for a mattress that functions as a mattress, keep scrolling. If you're looking for an oversized, overpriced dog bed that will also teach you a valuable lesson about reading the fine print — this is your guy. Would not recommend to my worst enemy. Would recommend to my neighbor who keeps parking in my spot.

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13867269452
Nov 28, 2025
Gator
2 out of 5 stars review

1 year review

1 year review of the medium mattress by a 230lb side sleeper: Month 1: Foam was is so thick, its cloud like. Felt more like a plush than a medium. Months 2-3: Perfect. Slept great. Months 4-5: Noticing the foam layers are beginning to lose their loft. Month 6: Foam is starting to bottom out, I began to feel the coil spring layer on my side. Months 8-9: Mattress foam was no longer providing any support. I felt as if i was sleeping on a firm coil spring bed. I began thinking I'm going to need a new mattress soon.. 12 months: Mattress has been replaced and now in the towns dump where it belongs. I had high hopes for this mattress but the long term just isn't there.

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13867269452
reply from Member's Mark Team

Thank you for sharing such a detailed account of your experience over the past year, Leroy. We’re glad the mattress provided comfort in the early months, but we’re truly sorry to hear that the support diminished over time and ultimately didn’t meet your expectations. We take durability concerns very seriously, especially for sleepers who need consistent support. Your feedback helps us identify where improvements are needed in our foam and coil design. We’d appreciate the chance to learn more about your experience and explore options that may better suit your comfort needs so please contact Member Support at (888) 301-0332.

Feb 4, 2026
Jamielee
1 out of 5 stars review

Terrible quality

I’ve been trying to buy a mattress for 3 years. I’ve bought memory foam and I hate it due to it making my hips hurt and I sink so far down into the bed I have to climb out. I thought this would be a good choice as it’s hybrid. No. I got it in a box all rolled up. Opened it and let it expand. I bought the ultra plush thinking it would be perfect. It has a zip cover on it and there was tons of slack like it was missing 1/4 of the mattress. The springs were sticking out really bad. I slept on it two nights and it caused horrendous back pain. I happened to have another 3inch memory foam mattress from a camper van I sold. I forced that mattress into the zip cover and I have salvaged it. No way was I going to try to return this as I would have probably had to haul it over an hour to my nearest Sam’s Club. But it was NOT worth the over 400$ I spent on it. I do not recommend.

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13867269452
Feb 20, 2026
Todd
1 out of 5 stars review

Run and Hide

Avoid at all costs. Mattress started to break down within weeks. And now I am dealing with customer service and that is a useless and extremely exhausting experience. Return started on 2-9 and it is 2-20 and I am still waiting for a call from the carrier. Have called Sam’s Club 5 times now and each time am told ATI will contact you in 24 to 72 hours. Do not buy a mattress from Sam’s. Quality is garbage and customer service is even worse!!!!

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13867269452
Jun 8, 2026
SweetPea
3 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

misleading size

This is not a true Queen size. Smaller

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13867269452
Jun 20, 2026
Chloe
1 out of 5 stars review

WHERE IS THE REST OF MY BED?

This bed is not a King size mattress- it is too short in length and too short in width, now I have gaps all throughout my bed frame. I wish I would have looked at the bad reviews first. It took forever to arrive as well - there were so many bad instances when ordering and receiving this bed. DO NOT BUY

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13867269452
Jun 10, 2026
CD
1 out of 5 stars review

Too soft and too difficult to return - hard pass

No need for anyone to sleep on the mattress purchased at our local store for our guest room. Purchased the medium firmness %26 knew as soon as we sat down on it that the mattress was FAR too soft and had little structure to it. After reading several reviews that claimed it was like sleeping on a brick, we felt confident this would be a supportive mattress for our guest room. We didn't even place sheets on it and offer it to a guest to sleep on because it was so soft. The sides also sink low when sitting on them because there is no structure to support it. The cover is far to big for the filling - a gap of about 3" . The mattress is not returnable to the local store. So, after calling and getting a "new A.I. agent" who only said it couldn't be returned because it cost too much, I made it to a human working in a call center who had such a bad connection it was hard to communicate with him. I was transferred again "to someone who could help me" who did put a request in to have the mattress picked up. Refunds are not issued until after the mattress is delivered to their warehouse after an outside company picks up. 24-72 hours for the delivery company to call to setup a pickup time , unclear how long that might take. Was told it takes 5-7 days AFTER pickup for item to make it to the warehouse to be processed for a return. So no, this mattress is not "hotel quality" in the slightest. Don't be fooled by the name on the box or sleek advertising. This is a HUGE waste of time %26 a poor quality product. Unfortunately one would not know this until you purchase the box %26 open the mattress because it is not open in store to try. I would not recommend this producte even for an occasionally used guest space.

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13867269452
Sep 28, 2024
Brenda
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Pleasantly surprised

I really love this mattress the bad thing is i dont want to get put of bed. It is very heavy which almost impossible to pick up to tuck sheets under.

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13867269452
reply from Performance Sleep Products

Hi Brenda - We are pleased to hear that you are happy with your purchase. Thank you for your review :)

Nov 23, 2024
KK and JJ
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Very good mattress!

We find this mattress to be very comfortable and supportive. The price is very good too! King size with medium firmness is what we purchased.

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13867269452
reply from Performance Sleep Products

Hi KK and JJ - We are pleased to hear that you are happy with your purchase. Thank you for your review :)

Jun 6, 2025
CW
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

To Soft

Returning this as soon as my new one arrives….this is not a good mattress for a bad back or neck. It is to soft for me.

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13867269452
reply from Member's Mark Team

We are sorry to learn the mattress is too soft for you, CW. Please know you can return or exchange the mattress with the Member's Mark 100% Satisfaction Guarantee. Please contact Member Support at (888) 301-0332 if you need assistance.