Great potato salad. The price is super affordable.

Everyone loves this potato salad.

So good

I found this potato salad very flavorful. It was creamy with just enough of each ingredient. The best thing about it for my family was the potatoes were actually cooked, tender but not mushy. Most potato salads the potatoes are to crunchy.

Wanted to reduce my kitchen time in preparation for a family cookout and decided to give this Amish Style Potato Salad a try. Everyone thought this was homemade and requested seconds. It was a hit!

This Potato salad is awful! The Amish would be discussed that you put their name on this. It is watered down and tastes awful. Save you money and shop somewhere else.

It is creamy and rich tasting with everyone raving about the taste and are surprised when we tell them it is MM at Sam's, my church uses it all the time when we have a function or feed the homeless during the winter!

I work in a senior living center, and our residents recently had this potato salad for a picnic. They loved the old-fashioned, flavorful recipe for this salad - in fact, one gentleman loved it so much that he asked for the leftovers to take back with him!

This used to be my go to when I don't have time to cook. This time it was not good. Very runny and too tart. I purchased 4 containers for Christmas, for a family gathering. I usually make homemade, but didn't have time. No one, including me liked it. I trashed it. Wouldn't recommend.

I really enjoy potato salad with a meal in the summer and I find this salad to be the best I have ever had in terms of deli type salad. I’ve tried potato salad from different grocery stores and I truly like this the best. Sam’s only carries it in the late spring and summer and then discontinues it in the fall and winter. So, you can’t find it all year. Or maybe it’s carried depending on your location.