Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Amish Style Potato Salad 5 lbs. for
Member's Mark Amish Style Potato Salad 5 lbs.
4.5 out of 5 stars
stars604 ratings157 reviews
  1. 5 stars75% (455)
  2. 4 stars13% (79)
  3. 3 stars6% (34)
  4. 2 stars2% (15)
  5. 1 star3% (21)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 131-140 of 157 reviews
Sep 9, 2022
lhfitz
2 out of 5 stars review

Too sweet

Hadn’t read the reviews before I purchased. Potatoes are cooked beautifully and the texture was very smooth w/out too much mayo. I doctored up with celery, Dijon mustard, and some salt but it still didn’t cut the sweet flavor - would not purchase again

Helpful?4A9H3YO4JYEF13837160068
Apr 29, 2022
Choose not to answer
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Too sweet

Don’t waste your money. This product was too sweet

Helpful?4A9H3YO4JYEF13837160068
May 6, 2023
Tennismom
3 out of 5 stars review

Where are the potatoes?

This used to be a great potato salad! Now, there's too much "sauce" and a lot fewer potatoes. I guess besides raising the price 40% over the last 2 years, this is another way to cheapen the product. Not happy.

Helpful?4A9H3YO4JYEF13837160068
Nov 30, 2022
Rexius
2 out of 5 stars review

Inconsistant

Often undercooked resulting in potatoes so hard that I end up throwing the whole tub away. But when they are properly prepared they are delicious and worthy of five stars. Crap shoot.

Helpful?4A9H3YO4JYEF13837160068
Aug 9, 2020
clhkmc
5 out of 5 stars review

Delicious

My family loves potato salad, we’ve tried just about every one that is ready made in store. This is hands down the best. Tastes just like homemade. So fresh. Will be buying again and again!

Helpful?4A9H3YO4JYEF13837160068
Jan 26, 2024
Ahn75
1 out of 5 stars review

Mashed potatoes, not potato salad!

COLD MASHED POTATOES not potato salad! This was the worst potato salad I’ve ever had. Potato salad is not supposed to be “smooth and creamy”. It’s supposed to be chunky. I don’t know how it got the good reviews I just don’t get it. PLEASE DO NOT BUY THIS!. It’s an affront to the Amish to put their name on this potato salad. Change brands. I was embarrassed to have to offer this to my luncheon guess but it was too late to either make my own or get another choice. I returned it without a problem as usual at Sam’s.

Helpful?4A9H3YO4JYEF13837160068
Jun 12, 2022
P in Philly
3 out of 5 stars review

It’s okay…

If you like a very creamy, mayonnaise-y potato salad. It is definitely heavy on the relish and mustard. Needs more potatoes and eggs to even it out

Helpful?4A9H3YO4JYEF13837160068
Aug 6, 2020
busy mom
5 out of 5 stars review

love this!

So I was always a “homemade is best” but making potato salad is time consuming. This brand is so close to homemade that it is so worth buying and saving yourself some time.

Helpful?4A9H3YO4JYEF13837160068
Feb 13, 2024
Wendie
1 out of 5 stars review

Used to be much better

I really liked this potato salad, until the last 2 times I bought it. They've decreased the potatoes and increased the dressing, and now it's a soupy mess. It puts the flavor off. All I taste is mayo, sugar, and vinegar.

Helpful?4A9H3YO4JYEF13837160068
May 1, 2022
Cathy
2 out of 5 stars review

Not bad if you like a really sweet potato salad.

I would not buy this again. I am not a fan. I bought this because they did not have the one I regularly purchase. I added a lot of extra celery, egg and Dijon mustard and my family ate it but wouldn't buy unless you like a really sweet potato salad.

Helpful?4A9H3YO4JYEF13837160068