The potatoes looked great, but many had those black or brown spots hiding inside. Fine for mashing since the bad spots can be cut out, but iffy for baking since you never know if the inside is good until it's done and ready to eat.

Best find at Sam's Club!! I love these giant potatoes because they are easy to peel ( I have Arthritis) AND I love making home -made french fries that are 5 or 6 inches long!!! So so good.

There was a couple of rotten potatoes in my bag which I didn’t know until I got home I had to empty bag and wash all of the potatoes but this was the first time I let them do my shopping for potatoes so I didn’t complain

These were no bigger than any other potatoes and as a whole were very disappointing. Sam's used to carry Green Giant Jumbo Potatoes, which were. These definitely weren't worth the trip.

These potatoes are usually giant size. But the last two times I bought them they were medium. Some have black spots under the skin but it’s normal bruising and perfectly safe to eat.

Quality has suffered in last year and price has increased. Never used to get bad potatoes but anymore I lose at least a quarter of the bag to bad potatoes.

Huge potatoes if you only like little spuds these aren't for you. We They are great stay fresh put on the butter and and you are ready to go! (after cooking)

These had alot of bad spots in them. This is inconvenient when you are baking potatoes and dont see the bad spot in the middle until it is time to serve them.

These potatoes are wonderful. I had been buying 5 pounds of potatoes from a local grocery store and the size of these were medium to small. These are LARGE AND LARGER!! They are fantastic potatoes. The price is good too. I will buy these again.

I buy these all of the time. I love a baked potato; and these are huge. It's a perfect pairing with soup/salad for a meal. The taste is always wonderful. I've also used them sliced for cooking and they work well.