Tastes like play dough

Bought 7 trays of these cookies (~420 cookies) for a huge birthday party and they were such a hit, there were NONE leftover! I'm so glad I sampled one of each before the party, otherwise, I never would have had a chance to try them since they were gobbled up so quickly! Great price, too!

Ordinarily we enjoy your cookies. This large batch was a giant failure. The cookies were not totally cooked, the middles were wet and the they all tasted like lemon extract. They look different, but all tasted the same. All were placed in the garbage.

Don't waste your money. The only cookie that the children (somewhat) ate were the birthday cake cookies. The only one that the adults could tolerate were the lemon cookies (barely). The cookies tasted very artificial and needed an extra 2-3 minutes in the oven for a soft, not crunchy cookie. Over 3/4 of the tray remained at the end of the event. So embarrassing. Considering the other baked goods that are enjoyed from Sam's Club, I expected much better.

The lemon over powers everything. They all taste of lemon.

The weirdest combination in the world. Don’t everrrrr make this again.

Not fond of these cookies … strange taste and they all tasted the same too!

Everything tasted the same!

The citrus flavor of the cookies made with that ruined the flavor of the other cookies.

Were dry, almost tasteless, or all tasted the same.