Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Home Run Inn Classic Cheese Pizza, Frozen 2 pk. for
Home Run Inn Classic Cheese Pizza, Frozen 2 pk.
4.9 out of 5 stars
stars3,253 ratings3,028 reviews
  1. 5 stars90% (2,923)
  2. 4 stars8% (251)
  3. 3 stars1% (41)
  4. 2 stars0% (9)
  5. 1 star1% (29)

Member photos

  • +2 images
Sort by |
Showing 61-70 of 3,028 reviews
Mar 7, 2026
JOB 28:28
2 out of 5 stars review

Love the simplicity of the pizza!

Bought this on valentine's day because the wife didn't want to order the heart shaped pizza as usual. The boys were gone doing their own thing and it wasn't the same for her as other years. I was out with a friend picking up our new dryer and he needed to stop by Meijer for a few things. I figured I would look for a plan cheese pizza, not a 4 or 5, or even a 3 cheese pizza. Just regular classic simple pizza, and that's what I found with Home Run Inn Pizza. The wife and I both really liked the pizza. The taste, the look, the smell, it was all around good. I just bought another one last week when I was out, just incase one of us wanted a good classic cheese pizza.

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401
reply from Customer Service

Thanks for giving us a shot! We're so glad to hear that you and your wife enjoyed our pizza, but would love to know how we could make it a 5-star experience the next time around. Here's to many more Home Run Inn pizza night!

Feb 5, 2026
Tedyus
5 out of 5 stars review

Cheesy Excellence

Having moved from Chicago to Sarasota, FL, one of the few things we really miss is Chicago thin style pizza. Thank goodness we can get Home Run Inn pizza at Publix. I love the crust and the cheese they smoother the pizza in is stupendous! Our go-to frozen pizza. Hey, HRI, how about opening some resturants down here?

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401
Feb 27, 2026
Scott from NYC
5 out of 5 stars review

The best Pizza in the frozen section

Over the past six months, I've probably bought, eaten and enjoyed 20 Home Run Inn Pizzas. Initially your Pizza was on sale, so I decided to give it a try. (It's one of the most expensive in the freezer case.) I grew up in New York City and then up to Connecticut so I have a lot of pizza experience. (Original Ray's in NYC, and Pepe's in CT.) Your pizza hits all the notes for a great pie. For me, it's the sauce! Your sauce is sweet and delicious. I think your sauce separates your Pizza from all others. And the way your cheese covers the whole pie is great, while your pre-cooking helps a lot. I only wish the stores around here carried more than a couple varieties, so I could try more of them. Glad I found you.

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401
Jan 22, 2026
Goldfish500
5 out of 5 stars review

A PHENOM

This is genuinely the best frozen pizza, it's got the best cheese out of any other frozen pizza and trust me I've had my share. I've worked pizza for comin on 9 years now and still I love what home run inn does for the soul. Do it. Buy it. I know you want to.

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401
Feb 9, 2026
Bootsie
5 out of 5 stars review

I admit I hide this in the freezer

I am a huge fan of this thin, thin crust pizza! So much that I tuck it in the back of the freezer so I can enjoy it when I prepare it for an evening by myself, watching my favorite movie and chowing down on this tasty, crispy treat. I love the balanced flavor of the sauce and the generous topping of ooy-gooey cheese.

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401
Feb 10, 2026
David68
5 out of 5 stars review

Best pizza on the planet!

We always have a Home Run Inn Pizza - 12 inch Family Classic Crust Cheese in the freezer. We love the buttery crust. The rich tomato sauce, just the right proportion to the delicious cheese. Home Run Inn is always a hit for the whole family on pizza night

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401
Mar 7, 2026
MaryB
5 out of 5 stars review

Best Frozen Pizza!

I have bought a lot of different frozen pizzas over the last few years, but Home Run Pizza is definitely my favorite. I always buy cheese pizza's and the cheese on these is delicious and plentiful. I like the amount of sauce used, not too much or to little and the crust also is flavorful. I feel like a hit a "home run" with this pizza!

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401
Mar 6, 2026
EMC50
1 out of 5 stars review

more cheese than pizza

I don’t know who approved the cheese-to-everything-else ratio on this pizza, but it was a crime. I was excited to try a new brand because it looked good and had great reviews… but this was easily the worst frozen pizza I’ve ever had. The cheese situation was out of control—so much that I literally had to peel most of it off just to make it edible. At one point I was basically eating crust with a little sauce because the cheese was just too much and had a weird texture. I’m not picky about frozen pizza, but this one was… an experience. Unfortunately, not a good one. Would not buy again.

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401
reply from Customer Service

We're sorry to hear about your most recent experience with our pizza. We take pride in the quality of our recipe, we're sorry to hear we missed the mark this time. Please do get in touch with our customer service team at info@homeruninn.com as we'd love for you to have a much better experience the next time around.

Jan 24, 2026
Kay Renée
5 out of 5 stars review

Best Frozen Pizza

No other frozen pizza compares to Home Run Inn! The delicious, buttery crust, perfectly melted cheese, and great sauce keep my family coming back again and again. It’s one thing everyone in the house enjoys. We were so thrilled when they started carrying these pizzas at our local grocery store. You won’t be disappointed with Home Run Inn!

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401
Mar 15, 2026
Ticky D UC
5 out of 5 stars review

Like homemade

I love this pizza because it is SIMPLY delicious!!! This is somebody's great, great, great, great grandmother's pizza sauce recipe; and it get's 7 stars. if you buy the cheese pizza only, you can add your favorite toppings like green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives, fresh orgegano, etc, you get the ideas ----and it is even more delicious!!!

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401