Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Home Run Inn Classic Cheese Pizza, Frozen 2 pk. for
Home Run Inn Classic Cheese Pizza, Frozen 2 pk.
4.9 out of 5 stars
stars
3,261 ratings3,033 reviews
  1. 5 stars90% (2,931)
  2. 4 stars8% (251)
  3. 3 stars1% (41)
  4. 2 stars0% (9)
  5. 1 star1% (29)
Sort by |
Showing 21-30 of 3,033 reviews
Apr 24, 2026
J Harris
4 out of 5 stars review

Good Pizza, Premium taste.

I like the the pizza overall, it is very rich buttery and has a premium feel and it keeps me full. The only criticism i can think of at the moment is the sauce. it is not bad but it does not have much taste/flavor (or not one that I can easily describe, it is very subtle, perhaps it just needs more sauce? ). I still like the pizza but sometimes it feels like cheese bread on a buttery crust. Again I like the pizza and will definitely eat it again (I will experiment with how I cook to see if it makes a difference).

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401
reply from Customer Service

Thank you for the thoughtful feedback! 🍕 We’re so glad you enjoy the rich, buttery crust and premium quality. We also appreciate your comments on the sauce- feedback like this helps us continue improving, and we’re happy to hear you’ll be giving us another try! Please reach out to us at info@homeruninn.com so we can discuss further.

Apr 19, 2026
Debb
5 out of 5 stars review

Yummy

We have been eating this pizza for years. We first discovered it when we moved to Illinois and have continued to eat it after moving out-of-state over 10 years ago. I was happy to see that readers of the Washington Post protested when that paper declared another brand of frozen pizza being the best. In response to all of the emails they received, they changed their recommendations and declared Home Run Inn as being the best frozen pizza!

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401
May 1, 2026
Pizza Patti
5 out of 5 stars review

the best frozen pizza

I LOVE Home Run Inn cheese pizza. Have recommended it a gazillion times to anyone who will listen to me. Crust is thin and fabulous. Cheese is distributed over entire pizza and not in big chunks. Sauce is perfectly flavored and does not overwhelm pizza. I do not buy any other frozen pizza. Just try it!!!!

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401
reply from Customer Service

We are so honored to have you as a loyal fan- Thank you!! ☺️

Mar 28, 2026
Mom2many
5 out of 5 stars review

The crust!! 😍

I love the crust on Home Run Inn pizzas! The edges often get a little too crispy before the bottom is crispy, but that might be my oven. We tend to lower the baking temp a bit. It’s still delicious and I will continue to purchase HRI to have on hand in my freezer.

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401
Mar 26, 2026
Dave
4 out of 5 stars review

Best frozen pizza in the Panhandle

I rarely buy frozen pizza, but when I do, it's Home Run Inn pizza here in the Panhandle of Florida. I am a transplanted Chicagoan by birth and always miss that unique flavor that comes with Chicago Pizza, I think it's fennel. Anytime I visit home, Joliet, I find my Aurelio's and love it but in the mean time it's Home Run Pizza. I buy the cheese and top it with my favorite ingredients. I wish I had Chicago Italian sausage down here. Home Run Pizza is as close as it gets to being back home!

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401
May 14, 2026
Bowleggs
5 out of 5 stars review

Cheeseeeeey Pizza

This pizza has been a staple for me and my family for decades and we LOVE going here to enjoy time with one another. I recently enjoyed a cheese pizza with my children to celebrate their Basketball Season. But, this year will be the first year we'll go to celebrate my mother on her 76th Birthday, and being without her will not be the same because Home Run Inn was her FAVORITE pizza!

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401
reply from Customer Service

Thank you so much for sharing something so personal with us. It means a great deal to hear that Home Run Inn has been part of your family’s memories and traditions for so many years. We’re honored your mom loved our pizza, and we hope being together at Home Run Inn continues to bring comfort and connection as you celebrate her memory. ❤️🍕

May 7, 2026
Majestic
5 out of 5 stars review

One perfect Cheese Pizza for me

Every week I make sure to grab a few pizzas from my local grocery store. Instead of going out, my husband and I opt to say in because there is no better frozen pizza than Home Run Inn! It's a comforting feeling, a Friday night vibe that makes us so bummed if for some reason we have to miss this weekly TGIF ritual.

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401
reply from Customer Service

That is incredibly special to hear- thank you for sharing that with us. Knowing Home Run Inn has become part of your Friday night tradition truly means the world to our team. There’s nothing better than hearing that our pizzas bring comfort, quality time, and something to look forward to each week. We’re honored to be part of your TGIF ritual with your husband, and we’ll do our best to keep making every pizza worthy of that tradition. 🍕❤️

Apr 19, 2026
Pizza Princess
5 out of 5 stars review

Absolutely the best frozen cheese pizza!

I have been eating this pizza for years! It is still my favorite! I moved from Ohio to Arizona 2 years ago and had a difficult time finding it but I kept searching and finally found it!! I rarely say this about anything but this pizza is perfect the cheese is flavorful and delicious, the sauce is sassy, and the crust is Bakery quality! I like that they pre-bake the pizza so when you take the plastic off the cheese doesn't all fall off. Please buy this you will love it forever!

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401
Apr 5, 2026
Hopscotch
5 out of 5 stars review

Tastes great! Better than expected!

Every year, we order a heart-shaped pizza on Valentine's Day from a local pizzeria. This year, plans were interrupted and my husband brought home a Home Run Inn Cheese Pizza. Instantly, I thought "cardboard" pizza. However, I was extremely surprised at how good it tasted, but must admit I was disappointed when we ran out! We don't eat a whole lot of frozen pizza in our home, but I can tell you this... we already have another Home Run Inn Cheese Pizza waiting for us in our freezer right now... and it won't take a whole year before we eat it, I guarantee that!

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401
Apr 2, 2026
Auntie S
5 out of 5 stars review

THE best frozen pizza

This is a staple in our house. We have three of them in our freezer currently and always have at least one on-hand. Sometimes we'll even make them on the grill! We rarely ever buy any other frozen pizza. We DO really miss the Plum Tomato pizza from years ago!!! Bring it back!

Review from Home Run Inn
Helpful?71OXPUDFI0JN13808812401