These cookies were so good. They were so soft and delicious . The frosting is really good and not very sweet.

We thought the cookie was okay. It's great with coffee and they look awesome! But the flavor was just okay.

Simple and not overly sweet. A perfect iced sugar cookie. Way better than those other soft iced cookies (in my opinion)

These weren't a big hit. No one ate at party. Then took them to another party and still no takers. Texture and taste okay, but not great. Mom is the only one who would eat them, surprisingly, because she doesn't like sprinkles.

Best christmas cookies ever !! I did not expect for them to be this good they are soft, so much flavor in them already planning on going back to get more, lol

This year's version (2024) are not very good. They are pretty and they are edible, but pretty much that is all I can say about these cookies (and I bought two packages yesterday, ugh!)

I read the other reviews and maybe my taste buds are wired differently, but I really liked them! They didn't have that “store bought” taste and more on the homemade side. They didn't knock you down with a sugar rush, like most processed cookies. Don't get me wrong, they're sweet, but they have a higher quality taste to them, if that makes sense. I'll buy them every year, as long as they keep selling them!

No idea how these got such good reviews. Of course they are cute but oh my do they taste terribly. I'm a big fan of Sam's bakery and I have a house of teenagers and kids that wouldn't even eat these cookies. I choked the first one down trying to acclimate, the rest are for the garbage. I really wanted them to be great!

I was so excited about finding these cookies but so disappointed when I tried one! The cookie had no taste at all ….it was terrible! My sister bought them last year and they were very good but they must've had a different baker or changed the recipe because they are tasteless! I have a whole unopened container left because I didn't want to waste them. Hopefully I can find someone to give them to.

There is something off about the taste of these. They start off as a good tasting cookie but when the aftertaste set in it feels and tastes like your mouth is coated in motor oil. We all brushed our teeth immediately and I threw the rest of the cookies away. It's whatever is in that chocolaty coating. Not good