I usually love Sam's Club apple pies. This pie was a mess. It looked beautiful. But the top and bottom crust were completely raw in the middle of the pie and the outer edges were about 10 degrees away from being burnt. I kept looking everywhere to see if I was supposed to bake it first, but I don't think so. I had to scoop the raw dough off and got some of the apples. They need more spices. They were really bland, just sweet no cinnamon. I suppose I could deconstruct the pie, spice it better, then cook the raw dough, but I don't think so.

I used to give 5 stars to the Members Mark apple pies, but not any more. I have had two of the pies over the past 4 months. Both my wife (who loves sweets) and I found these Honeycrisp Apple Pies to be far too sweet for our palates. Maybe it's because Sam's switched to Honeysweet apples. I any case, we will never again buy one of these apple pies. The price is right, though.

BEST APPLE PIE IVE EVER EATEN. Please- never quit selling these!!!

The crust was not good at all. Mushy and flavorless.

heaven on Earth

Best ever try

I bought this pie for thanksgiving but the apples inside of it weren't cooked all the way. They were very crunchy. So disappointing

Pie was not fully baked apples were still hard . Pie crust was still doughy. Load with tons of sugar .

One of the best apple pies I have had. I am a baker and have made hundreds of apple pies through the years. I never expected the taste and quality of this item...truly delicious...only problem is cutting it without breaking...

Great pie, good crust to filling ratio very well seasoned filling with flaky tender crust lots of sliced apples. You can't go wrong for the price, size, and taste.