I will not be buying this ever again. The apples were still raw and the crust as well as the lattice were so thick you couldn't even cut the pie! I sat there and chizzled away at it for over 30 minutes.

Picked up an apple pie on monday, march 3rd. It was overcooked and tasted terrible. I would not have chosen it if i went into the store. Unfortunately, I am handicapped and depend on pick up services.

I'm new to the Sam's Club world, so to me it's been exciting trying a bunch of desserts that the bakery has. I seen this pie last week and decided to add that to this week's cheat day Saturday menu. I went back and forth reading the reviews and was almost not going to get it I was worried that it was going to be extremely soggy like some of the reviews said or under baked because other than the top that was really no way to tell how it was cooked underneath. So last night I went in and bought

I used to give 5 stars to the Members Mark apple pies, but not any more. I have had two of the pies over the past 4 months. Both my wife (who loves sweets) and I found these Honeycrisp Apple Pies to be far too sweet for our palates. Maybe it's because Sam's switched to Honeysweet apples. I any case, we will never again buy one of these apple pies. The price is right, though.

Was hesitant about buying the pie because of some of the negative reviews, but I was pleasantly surprised at how tasty it was. Heated it up at 350 degrees for 20 minutes and my guests were impressed by the quality and taste. Will be picking up another on my next trip to Sam's.

I usually love Sam's Club apple pies. This pie was a mess. It looked beautiful. But the top and bottom crust were completely raw in the middle of the pie and the outer edges were about 10 degrees away from being burnt. I kept looking everywhere to see if I was supposed to bake it first, but I don't think so. I had to scoop the raw dough off and got some of the apples. They need more spices. They were really bland, just sweet no cinnamon. I suppose I could deconstruct the pie, spice it better, then cook the raw dough, but I don't think so.

Always excellent and a great favorite.

heaven on Earth

Best ever try

I bought this pie for thanksgiving but the apples inside of it weren't cooked all the way. They were very crunchy. So disappointing