Three words best describe these: Quality, Quality, and Quality! These potatoes are always fresh and nice and consistent in size and flavor. I would not buy potatoes anywhere else.

Have bought the red potatoes many times and they have been very goo and very fresh. However, this last bag was very bad, within 1 week there were many soft, rotten potatoes. Had to discard most of bag.

Bad spots in every potato I have used so far and that has been half of them. You need to peel 2 potatoes to make sure you have enough good potato. Will not buy again.

Pretty much each potato was damaged with some kind of rot. Looked like small scratches from the outside, but about 30-50% of potato went to garbage. Yes, I know, I should have paid attention before buying. Just did not expect it from Sam's Club.

I prefer red potatoes for all of my potato dishes. They have a great flavor and can be used to mash, fry or bake. They never disappoint! And the price is great!

These red potatoes were the main ingredient in a fried potato dish and they were excellent and delicious. With Sam’s we have never received a bag of similar items where there were several bruised or rotten and this time was the same. Recommend!

We use these potatoes during the holidays. I made potato salad and mashed potatoes out of them. Highly recommend. Stayed fresh for a good amount of time.

I was very disappointed in the red skin potatoes after a couple of days they started getting buds on them forcing me to use them right away and I still had to throw some away

Starts rooting within days of purchase and also had too many uneven surfaces so difficult to peel. Otherwise good potatoes if u r consuming within a few days the entire huge bag!

Red potatoes are my favorite, and buying the ten pound bag is great for my use. My only complaint is there's often too much moisture accumulation, likely due to how they stack them on top of each other.