[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love Skrewball peanut butter whiskey so much! I think it’s best when you chill a glass and put the whiskey in the freezer for a bit. It leaves a warm aftertaste even though it’s chilled. I like sipping on a little bit of it for the night, I haven’t tried mixing it with anything else bc it’s perfect on its own! I’ve tried other brands and Skrewball has the best taste.

I love this stuff❤️ I had never heard of it before I saw a TV ad for it. I love anything peanut butter tasting, so I bought this on a whim at the store. As soon as I got home I opened it and poured a glass. WOW! It was so good. I really did not expect it to have a sweet taste. It is very smooth going down. I have tried some other peanut butter whiskeys, but they do not even come close to the perfection that is SKREWBALL! Now I buy it all the time.

It's the only whiskey I buy ! ! How you manage to make it that smooth I'll never know. Since the first bottle I tried I started buying peanut butter flavored coffee pods. I make one with 4oz water and keep in refrigerator. When I'm ready for my drink I put it over ice with 1 1/2 shots of Screwball and fill with almond milk. It is my heaven in a glass.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I’ll be honest—I didn’t know what to expect from a peanut butter whiskey, but Screwball completely won me over. From the first sip, it’s smooth, slightly sweet, and packed with rich peanut butter flavor that somehow manages to feel indulgent without being overpowering. Very smooth consistency! What really impressed me is how versatile this whiskey is. I’ve used it in multiple cocktails—from creamy dessert-style drinks to lighter, fun mixed cocktails—and it shines every single time. It blends beautifully without getting lost, and it adds a unique depth that instantly elevates any drink. Whether mixed, shaken, or poured over ice, it’s incredibly approachable and dangerously easy to sip. Straight up, it’s silky and warming. Mixed, it becomes playful and creative. It’s one of those bottles that sparks inspiration—every time I reach for it, I’m already thinking about the next drink I want to make. Perfect for entertaining, experimenting with cocktails, or just enjoying something a little different than your standard whiskey. If you like bold flavors, dessert cocktails, or simply want a bottle that stands out on your bar cart, Screwball is has excellent consistency and is a must-have. 🥃🥜 Would I buy it again? Absolutely. Would I recommend it? 100%.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] if you like peanut butter you'll love this whiskey I'm a big whiskey drinker and I enjoyed it for the most part it makes great shots and it's moving up that you can drink it on the rocks it's very peanut strong like it tastes like peanut butter so it goes good in like chocolate peanut butter Martini but you get the idea you know

Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey is best understood not as a traditional whiskey, but as a sweet, dessert-style flavored spirit that leans heavily into its peanut butter identity. On the nose, it delivers an immediate hit of roasted peanuts, peanut brittle, and caramel-like sweetness, which carries straight through to the palate.

It has been a while since I bought this product. The first time I tried it while it was room temperature. I could taste the peanut butter flavor just fine. I put the bottle in my refrigerator to chill it. I say I prefer it chilled. It goes down smooth and tastes delicious. I will buy it again when I have extra money. Right now, I need all my money for necessities.

Best price in the Northland

Extremely tasty whisky. Comparable to the peanut butter flavored vodka…

I really enjoy the unique flavor of this whiskey. I am certainly not a connoisseur, but for a nice little cocktail it’s perfect.