The nectarines that were in a peach box were fine if I had wanted nectarines. They are good, but don't act quite the same in a peach pie as peaches. Too much juice and shrinkage, so it is too soupy for a good peach pie. Taste is close, so not the problem.

It's peach season so good peaches are available everywhere EXCEPT Sam's. Peaches skip ripening and turn to mealy mush when they've been improperly refrigerated. It could have been at the packer or the shipper, but Sam's always has pallets of refrigerated food sitting in the aisles. Peaches may be a little too delicate for Sam's business model.

They were delicious, with just enough firmness to eat like an apple. As with everything purchased at Sam’s you buy more than you can use right away, so we had to eat them quickly or they would spoil. Still, they were better and cheaper than at the local supermarket.

I usually get my peaches from Kroger’s,but I decided to try the peaches from Sam’s .It was a major disappointment.The peaches were very hard and never did .They tasted like sour apples.The price were expensive too.Stop selling peaches that are like large sour apples!!!

The peaches were inedible, I won't be buying them again. Don't know how or why, but they were strangely hard, as if they were unripe, but at the same time when sliced open showed signs of being almost rotten. All I can guess is that they were frozen in transit something. Worst "PEACH" ever.

I enjoy having a fruit smoothie for breakfast. These usually taste great. Sometimes they will be more tart than I like but mixing with other fruits doesn't cause my smoothie to have a bitter taste. Sometimes they are too ripe so I will need to cut them up & put in freezer bags. Making a smoothie with frozen fruit is not an issue. Most of the time they will last in the refrigerator for a week but if they are ripening too quickly I will freeze them.

For store bought I would have given them 5 stars. I gave it a 4 only because we have peach orchards locally and you just can't beat that. I had stopped buying the beautiful peaches in stores years ago because they are horrible but these were really good. I took a chance on them because when i walked by the smell was amazing. I will be buying these again

I love peaches from Sam’s club. It is worth noting that the title says yellow peaches and there are different varieties of yellow peaches available every 2 weeks from May through September. So if you get a bad batch, you can try again in a week or two and the flavors will be different. Typically the peaches available at the beginning of the season aren’t the sweetest. The more flavorful peaches come in June. End of the season peaches tend to be more mealy in my experience but not always! If you walk into the store and purchase in person, look at the flavors descriptions on the bag or box. I think I only had 1 or 2 bag of peaches that were just mediocre. The rest of the peaches for summer 2024 were great! (Also worth noting the peach farms are all within 30 minutes of Sam’s club since I live in Californias Central Valley. Our peaches are fresh off the trees.)

These peaches were the only ones I have bought in past few years at a retail store that were actually really good. Most times the peaches are picked too early to be able for them to be ripe at the store when purchasing them and therefore they are not worth buying.

These peaches were disappointing. I purchased them for my summer students as well we're reading James and the Giant Peach. The peaches from Sam's Club were not sweet as a peach should be and they definitely were not juicy. To redeem them (as well as feeling sorry that my students were given these to eat), I drove an hour to Porter to pick up "real" peaches from an orchard. The comparison was drastically different. I compared the two peaches, and the ones from Sam's Club were not only twice and a half the cost more, but they were much smaller in size and less bright of that orange and yellow peach color. I'll not purchase peaches from Sam's again.