I'm giving this 5 stars only because I want more ppl to see this review. I looked back and saw I bought 4 of these cakes btwn Dec and Feb 24/25. The cakes sold now have a changed recipe and downgraded ingredients. The cakes last year were moist and firm and topped with cream cheese frosting with coconut. A very complimentary cake. This cake 12/25 is very different. It is a dry cake with a cheap, too sweet, slightly whipped (definitely not cream cheese) frosting. I won't buy anymore of this cake. I'll be throwing out what is left because 1 piece was enough for me. So sorry all the bakeries are changing the recipes that work to something disappointing. Sam's Club, please look into the 1-4 star reviews and give consideration to the complaints. Thank you. 12/26/25. k

This cake was a huge hit! Only My mom makes an homemade Italian Cream cheese cake that tops this one. But seriously, you cannot make this cake at home for this price, so we tried this scrumptious delight to save time and we will definitely do it again.

This cake is delicious. It's only around during the holidays so we try to get a few and freeze them. So good!

This cake is the grossest cake I ever tried. I had to throw it away as nobody out of 12 people liked it.

Delicious cake and made with top notch ingredients. I took this cake to a holiday party and everyone was raving about the delicious cake!

Only wish it was offered year round! Instead we have to freeze it and it's not fresh. Please offer year round!! Italian is not a season.

This cake is absolutely amazing. I've purchased this cake 3 times & ever time it gets bette and better

The cake was good but felt it was a little dry for Italian Cream cake. Probably would not purchase again because of this experience.

The Italian Creme Cake was amazing. I got many great reviews from my colleagues of the cake being very delicious.

This cake was not the best. Supposedly the new substitute for their old delicious coconut cake. It was disappointing.