Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Pimento Stuffed Manzanilla Olives, 2 pk. for
Member's Mark Pimento Stuffed Manzanilla Olives, 2 pk.

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 421-430 of 458 reviews
Jan 27, 2024
Greg G
1 out of 5 stars review

Bad taste. Just not very good.

I have purchased Walmart brand olives like this so I thought the member mark would be the same. Boy was I wrong. These olives are bland and have a very rank flavor. Can not recommend these to anyone. I would return, but I opened a jar.

Helpful?1Q433XQYRRJG13636265901
May 15, 2025
Fred T
2 out of 5 stars review

Watch for pits!

The flavor is great however, beware of pits! I sampled 25 olives and 5 (20 percent) still had pits in them. This could be a bad batch (9396834518), however I will not purchase these again.

Helpful?1Q433XQYRRJG13636265901
Jan 11, 2024
Lynn B
1 out of 5 stars review

Bring back the Queens!

Was so disappointed when I went to buy the Mario Queen olives and these small things were in their place . No self respecting martini or antipasto salad would be caught dead dressed with these little things! Please bring back the Queen!

Helpful?1Q433XQYRRJG13636265901
Nov 3, 2023
CP
1 out of 5 stars review

Very poor replacement product

Please bring back the Greek green olives that were exceptional; firm, large, and flavorful. The new replacement olives are mushy and of low quality. Please bring back the Greek olives. I would happily pay more for them.

Helpful?1Q433XQYRRJG13636265901
Jun 23, 2024
Jo
2 out of 5 stars review

Not suitable replacement for a Members Mark brand

I didn't care for these olives. They have a somewhat bitter taste even tho they are packed in glass. The salt level is off as well. I tried using them in a dip recipe to disguise the taste but it came thru anyway. And the label is slapped on crooked. That sounds pety but it let's people know they do not really care about the quality of this product .

Helpful?1Q433XQYRRJG13636265901
Apr 5, 2025
ESams
1 out of 5 stars review

The worst tasting olives I've ever had

The first time I bought these olives, they were under-ripe and thus were tasteless and wooden in texture. I thought I'd give them another try when I saw them at the club a second time where they looked less yellow and more green. These second purchase was worse yet - by far the worst tasting olives I've ever had. In fact I can't recall any bad tasting olives other than these, an indication that I'm not picky. I wish Sam's would stop replacing good brands like Mario's with far inferior Member's Mark products.

Helpful?1Q433XQYRRJG13636265901
Nov 19, 2023
Mamaw1106
5 out of 5 stars review

Best olives ever

These are the best olives we've ever had. Usually a jar this size sits in the fridge for a few months before it's gone. We went through half a jar of these in less than a week. Sam's please make these a permanent stock item instead of limited time only. And please don't change them. They're amazing.

Helpful?1Q433XQYRRJG13636265901
Sep 14, 2023
Thick waisted man
3 out of 5 stars review

Great deal, sad that they're out of stock

I have been buying these for months and we go through 2 jars in about 2 weeks. The price is insanely cheap! Less than $4 per jar and they're $22 per jar elsewhere. I've tried other brands, but these are the best I've found. Just the right snap and a bright and salty flavor. Perfect to sandwich between some salty meats and cheese. Delicious and inexpensive.

Helpful?1Q433XQYRRJG13636265901
Apr 18, 2025
bjensen48k
4 out of 5 stars review

I have a fix for these...

I love olives, I always have. I'm the relative that shows up for the holiday party and is escorted to the olive tray. Im that guy. Anyway. These are quality olives in an unimpressive brine. It's as if the product was processed in the correct bath and packaged in something else. So, as a person that needs quality brine for a dirty martini, I needed to find a fix. Math helped out. These olives have 75mg of sodium per serving. Other brands have over 200mg. To get these olives to that range sodium must be added. After careful calculation, and real world testing, I found the fix. Add 2 teaspoons of kosher salt to the jar after opening. Close, shake and let sit in the fridge for a week. Your olives are now ready to enjoy. You are welcome. ;)

Helpful?1Q433XQYRRJG13636265901
Jan 23, 2024
Tabitha
3 out of 5 stars review

Horrible

You use to have a 2 pack of a name brand same size as these not the big ones they are yuck to. The name brand 2pk small ones they were good members mark brands just horrible. I don't recommend unless you can return them if you don't like them either. I'm going to try and return these I opened just 🤮 yuck.

Helpful?1Q433XQYRRJG13636265901