I always get these pies throughout the year, they normally taste amazing, but the one I purchased for thanksgiving was burnt tasting and the filling want that great either. If this is the turnout I will not purchase again.

I wouldn't buy again. Some guess liked it. I'm use to home made. Maybe just a matter of taste buds. It was recommended to me by a family member whose family likes it. Try it for yourself. I didn't care for the texture.

I ordered these online for pickup for Thanksgiving but they were passed the use by date and very dry. Guests were polite and asked for ice-cream. Moral of the story is to shop in person!

Sam's Member Mark pecan pie was the best store-bought pie I've found. Went to Sam's to buy a few of them and was told that they no longer carry them. Does anyone tell me why it was discontinued?

the BEST PiE! please do not change this recipe (like I hear you did the the French silk pie!! 😭) these 2 pies are our go to pies for Thanksgiving and Christmas! This is a fantastic pie and I certainly hope it's back in stock soon so I can take one to our Christmas party!

Purchased for Thanksgiving. The filling was runny and wouldn't hold its shape at all. It didn't really taste like anything either. We ended up throwing almost all of it away. The quality of several items at Sam's has really gone down in the past few years. It seems like they're cutting corners and choosing profit over quality.

I'm not sure how they do it, but this pie is really good: not cloyingly sweet.

I purchase this pie for every holiday event and it is a hit. Very, very good.

Not that good but good size and price

Amazing! Delicious, great value.