My family is from Texas and we always have pecan pie at Thanksgiving. We loved this Sam's pie at last year's Thanksgiving dinner and couldn't get enough of it. I went out of my way to drive an hour away to the nearest club to get it again for our Thanksgiving party this year. Literally, no one liked it this year. It seems like the recipe changed and the custardy filling was overly sweet, overwhelming the pecan flavor. I couldn't taste any spices. It's just like most average mass-produced versions I can find anywhere. I couldn't even finish a slice, even though I'm never one to not clean my dessert plate. It didn't have the fresh, nutty, homemade taste as we thought of it last year. So disappointed.

I used to get this regularly, and it was almost as good as home-made. Fresh nuts and flaky crust. HOWEVER, I bought one the other day and literally could not eat it. Had to throw it away. (I live 2 hours from the nearest sams, too far just for a return) Some of the nuts were old, and the crust was literally inedible, and tasted horrible. Some places not done, some very hard, and other places were grainy..like eating dirt. I cannot tell you how disappointed I was. The pie used to be so wonderful.

I looooove pecan pie and I bought it and the sweet potato pie to take to my friends house for Thanksgiving. I chose to keep the pecan for myself. Oh my!! So yummy! The crust was flaky and top loaded with pecans but...the filling...that filling!! Thick and caramelly. I cut it up and froze it and ate a piece later and it was even better. You can mildly taste the nutmeg and cloves. So delicious.

My daughter wanted to try this pie. Their pumpkin and apple pie are very good but this was a miss for us. It was a custard layer topped with roasted pecans. The pecan pies we have eaten always had pecans throughout with a more caramelized the pie filling. Love so many of their baked goods but we actually did not finish this pie and moved on to the apple pie.

Not good

Cheaper at other sams

Too much sugar

We threw much of it out

Too dry

Very much delicious