Bought two cases at two different times. Both had issues with a ton of clumpy solids on the bottom that wouldn't break down at all. I shook them constantly while I was drinking them to try and get the sludge off the bottom, but it never mixed. I ended up with a mouth full of lumpy mess, and I still had to blast them with water to clean them out for recycling.

This is my favorite premier protein shake flavor that I can still find. Banana, Blueberry Oat and Apple Oat were my ride or die. I could drink these straight out of the bottle. However I have not been able to find these flavors anymore. So I am grateful for cake batter and loving it blended with a frozen banana, ice and a few blueberries. This one comes and goes on Sam’s Club website. It also looks like it has been hit with another price increase. I still love this flavor and pray that it sticks around!

I have bought many of the various flavors offered over the years. Yet, I hadn't tried THIS one before… It doesn't taste anything like cake batter. It tastes like their vanilla shakes with a hint of cinnamon. Not horrible, but not like cake mix at all. It's quite sweet, too. Mine weren't lumpy (yet), although most of the Premiere shakes get that way over time. As I only use them for a quick meal replacement (before heading out to run errands/do yard work), and normally drink them as fast as I can (simply to get some protein), I don't ever sit around just savoring/enjoying ANY of these shakes. Yes, I'll chug-through the rest of the case…but, I won't be buying this one again; I'll stick to the chocolate, as I think it has the best taste overall.

These are my favorite Premier Shakes! I use these as coffee creamer and they are so good! I mix them half and half with the Cafe Latté but they are so hard to find. PLEASE put them in stores instead of the caramel or other weird flavors. This and the Cafe Latté are the best of all the flavors unless you want basic chocolate or vanilla (I don't). They are hard to find everywhere and sell out so fast online. It would be awesome to get them inside Sam's stores!

I can always taste artificial sweeteners when present, but can overlook it if it’s not too overbearing. These drinks have much more of an artificial taste than the other protein shakes we’ve had. The cake batter taste is much more subtle than I hoped. We’ll finish these, but won’t buy them again.

When I order these drinks from Sam's, they inevitably come with chunks in them. I'm not sure if it's the temp they're stored at or the length of time they've been sitting in the warehouse. If I order the 4-pack from Kroger at $9.99 a piece, I never get a chunky shake. I'm willing to pay more for not gagging on chunks of protein. Blechh!!

This flavor was a little too sweet for me

A solid way to get in 30 grams of protein. Easy to drink and easy to mix with coffee.

Taste good! Shake well before drinking serve chilled

Was really sweet treating. Does taste like a cake batter.