When I read the reviews, I thought ok I'll give Premier another chance. Shake was very watery and had little taste. Fairlife shakes are so much better.

I do like it a lot. It's a good flavor. It does taste similar to some vanilla drink I have had. I want to say slimfast. I can't pin point it. But it's pretty good regardless

PLEASE GET THIS BACK IN STOCK!!!! The best since they took French vanilla away! Put this in the freezer and freeze it then cut the rop off and eat like ice cream!! Yummy

Not a huge vanilla fan, but decided to give this a try. So glad I did! Me and my husband both loved the flavor and it really does taste like cake batter!

I love cake batter flavored items. I also buy other premier protein products. However, this cake batter shake is among the worst that I have tasted. It is definitely the worst product that premier protein has come out with. Save your money.

I am like a scientist and I am always happy with the flavor that I make Chocolate with caramel and then mocha…Vanilla with birthday cake…I add nutmeg to the caramel to make like a egg nog flavor.

This stuff is amazing! It tastes like a milkshake not a protein shake but keeps you full for a long time like a protein shake. My favorite flavor of these shakes I've tried. 30 grams of protein for only 160 calories can't be beat. Cannot recommend highly enough!

I have to drink 3 protein shakes a day, as I am a post-op bariatric patient. I actually really liked Cake batter flavor. I don't particularly care for Chocolate drinks though. This one was definitely sweeter tasting, which I enjoyed since I cut sweets out completely.

I usually love cake batter flavor so was excited to see this and purchased the 12-pack. Unfortunately all of them have had clumps in it so far (I opened my 5th one today). It's pretty gross. You can only shake the bottle so much - and it still doesn't help break up the clumpiness of it. I may try putting it in the blender and mix it up with some yogurt and ice. We'll see. I hope they improve on it as I'd like to see the flavor stay but it needs some improvement. If they're able to improve it, I will recommend to a friend but until then, no.

I HATE when protein shakes have a nasty after taste. Thank God that was not the case with this Cake Batter flavor. I have tried other protein shakes that advertise this flavor and turn out to be absolutely disgusting. It's very important to me to find great tasting shakes because I need to be able to stay motivated and no one stays motivated if the product is gross. This is not gross. This is bomb!!!