An ice cream sandwich should have a hard crisp cookie on the outside,however, every time (with the exception of once) that I buy these the cookie part is soft and sticks to my fingers. So disappointed because I know they are not supposed to be like this. Seems they had melted then refrozen. Or their refrigerator is not cold enough.

This ice cream tastes bad. The ice cream part is the way to sweet, I couldn't tell the creamy ice cream, all I tasted was sugar and artificial flavor. The cookie part tasted like old soft chocolate cookie. After several bites, I had to throw mine away. My husband bought those, guess he is going to finish all other leftover ones.

There’s nothing special about this ice cream sandwich. Well, maybe I’m special (slow) for buying it. It’s much smaller and doesn’t taste any better than any other ice cream sandwich. DON’T WASTE YOUR MONEY! Would’ve returned it but a friend ate one out the box too. He’s not a fan either.

They taste great. Hope Sam's continues to carry FatBoy Ice Cream Sandwiches.

These are one of the family favorites. They’re so delicious.

While I would not call them fat I would say it does have a good amount of nice vanilla ice cream. Keep it up Boys!

We recently bought some for the grands they love them and so do i best ice cream sandwich we have ever tasted

My spouse loved these, but I thought they were so salty. Considering how many great reviews, maybe I got an off batch. Will not buy again.

Now this is an ice cream sandwich. Nice thick and creamy vanilla ice cream center. Just the right size. Far superior to the super market brands!

Simply the best - much better than the bargain Kemps or store brands. Sam's Club is the only place local that seems to sell them.