Member's Mark Sliced Colby Jack Cheese is everything I never knew I needed in a cheese. It's rich, creamy, perfectly marbled, and so dangerously delicious that I have to remind myself it's meant for sandwiches, not just snacking straight from the pack. Every slice tastes like it was crafted specifically to make my taste buds dance. The 2‑lb size is a total win, too plenty to share, but honestly, you'll want to keep it all for yourself. If you're looking for cheese that's as bold as it is smooth, this Colby Jack is an absolute must‑try.

When Sam's Club stopped carrying the Cabot version of this cheese, I was hesitant to buy the Members Mark version. However, after I decided to try it, I was glad I did. This is great to use for grilled cheese sandwiches as it melts well. Great cold, too.

Consistently great cheese. Always delicious and a great value for the amount you get. If you're a sandwich or cheese person it's an amazing price. The only downside is it's probably too much cheese, we sometimes can't finish before it starts going bad. Just be ready to eat your hearts fill.

This sliced Colby cheese is my grandchildren's favorite cheese. They can eat the whole thing in a weekend.

This sliced cheese is consistently good. I also like the sharp cheddar. The slices are even and the resealable packaging is great.

These are a great size and taste but very hard to separate as they do not have paper between the slices. They tend to break trying to get the slices apart. You have your hands all over the stack trying to get slices apart risking mold growth even from the cleanest of hands. Very frustrating, Please Fix!! Otherwise 5 *

I Only buy this on a pinch for some reason it seems to like to stick together and break apart when trying to use it at least half of the time . I think it gets frozen after its packaged and thats why it breaks apart. It does taste fine

I bought this for the convenience of having pre-sliced colby jack after years of using the block of Tillamook brand cheese sold by Sam's. It is a lot easier than breaking out my cheese cutter every time I want a cracker with cheese. It is also less expensive. However, the flavor is a disappointment and I will not make the same purchase again.

This cheese is very good if you can eat it within the first week or two of opening. After that it grows mold, even though the expiration date is months away. This has happened several times with each of the natural cheese that has been purchased. I usually just throw them away but decided to bring it up to a customer service agent and was told to bring it back in the future.

This cheese is just a big block that is supposed to be sliced, but is impossible to peel apart. Really can't even use or eat it properly.