Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Red Baron Pepperoni & Four Cheese Deep Dish Singles Frozen Personal Pizza Combo, 69.60 oz., 12 PK for
Red Baron Pepperoni & Four Cheese Deep Dish Singles Frozen Personal Pizza Combo, 69.60 oz., 12 PK
4.6 out of 5 stars
stars
6,377 ratings1,220 reviews
  1. 5 stars78% (4,988)
  2. 4 stars12% (762)
  3. 3 stars6% (356)
  4. 2 stars2% (116)
  5. 1 star2% (155)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 51-60 of 1,214 reviews
Feb 17, 2024
josh846
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Amazing little pizzas

Best mini pizzas. We get these and throw them in the air fryer for a few minutes. The cheese ones we add ham or pepperoni to with about 2 minutes left in the air fryer. I like also theowing some mikes hot hiney on them to add a little sweet and spicy kick. Of course theya re great by themselves. Ylwe have also microwaved them for 1 minute then finish in the air fryer just to crisp them up. Either way is great. This is a quick easy meal when we dont have time to cook. Everyone enjoys them.

Helpful?3COWCM1DK5OX13610718589
May 25, 2021
JessSs
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Pretty tasty

My kids love these, and they actually cook up pretty nice in the microwave. Obviously the crust isn't too crunchy in the microwave, but they are deep dish crust, and it's not too mushy, and can get a little crispy, if wanted by cooking in the oven or pizza maker.

Helpful?3COWCM1DK5OX13610718589
Nov 9, 2024
H T
4 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

One of the better frozen pizzas

Good size for a modest lunch or big snack. The crust had a perfectly fine texture, and crisped well in an oven. The sauce wasn't too tangy or sweet, and while the cheese wasn't particularly flavorful it was acceptable. There was a fair amount of cheese, sauce, and meat. A good buy if you can get them for under a dollar a pie.

Helpful?3COWCM1DK5OX13610718589
Sep 22, 2016
OKchaser2112
5 out of 5 stars review

VERY good, especially for the price.

I see great reviews for these pizzas when they're microwaved. I've never had them cooked that way, but I imagine they would be great. We always cook them in the oven. They come out great. The crust is firm without being hard. They're a little on the saucy side. My husband doesn't like a lot of sauce, but he thinks they're okay. I like lots of sauce and wish they had a bit more. I can eat one with a few tots. He can eat 2 and some tots. At about $1 each, the quality is amazing for the price.

Helpful?3COWCM1DK5OX13610718589
Apr 7, 2026
JOHN
1 out of 5 stars review

Too much sauce and oregano, and too expensive

These are pretty bad. The four cheese ones have loads of sauce, which is way too heavy on the oregano, probably to mask the not so ripe tomatoes used. The pepperoni are better. The size is a decent meal for a regular appetite. These are also over-priced for the poor quality. The Sabatasso's brand available elsewhere tastes much better and is less expensive, although the individual pizzas are a little smaller. Honestly, Sam's needs ditch this over-priced, poor quality product in favor of a Member's Mark equivalent designed custom for Sam's and put through extensive taste testing. I'm sure it would taste better and be priced more competitively than this national brand Red Baron junk.

Helpful?3COWCM1DK5OX13610718589
Mar 12, 2025
Paula
3 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Black mold frozen pizza right from the box

I question the handling on these and will likely not purchase them ever again. I thought they were good the first time I bought a case cuz we didn't have any incident and ate them all. I bought a second case a few weeks later that I put in the freezer in promptly forgot about. I recently bought a third case for getting about the second that was in my outdoor freezer. And as soon as I open this one to put them away in my kitchen freezer I noticed one of them was mostly black. Of course I found this troubling so left it out to thaw so I could get a better look and understanding of what it was. it was black furry mold just as I suspected. I immediately requested a refund which Sam's obliged but they didn't ask for a photo and didn't get any information except for that there was something wrong with it. I only took a picture of the frozen one and not after a thawed. I've already discarded them but I'll attach the picture of the black frozen pizza. My recommendation is to never buy these cuz who knows how they're handled if it can set out and grow that amount of mold and then be refrozen to be sold to the customer.

Helpful?3COWCM1DK5OX13610718589
Aug 13, 2009
MomCassie
5 out of 5 stars review

Excellent Personal Pizzas

These cook evenly, have good flavor and good texture. They are a nice size for a light meal or a heavy snack. They cook nicely in the toaster oven when following the oven directions. If you have ever purchased those 99 cent store-brand personal pizzas you know they are flat and not necessarily of great quality but usually edible. These come out to less than 99 cents per pizza (currently $10.76 for 12 pizzas is just under 90 cents per pizza) and are clearly superior to the alternative in flavor, texture, and even appearance. These are definitely a good buy.

Helpful?3COWCM1DK5OX13610718589
Aug 2, 2025
Bruce
3 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Crusty

First they had reflective trays for cooking in the microwave. Then they had reflective flat panels. Now, nothing, and keeping them in the microwave until everything is cooked (unfrozen and edible) creates a crust that you seemingly could break your jaw biting into. Other than that, the taste is what you might expect.

Helpful?3COWCM1DK5OX13610718589
Aug 14, 2020
Anonymous
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Great pizzas!!

This is the first time I've tried Red Baron Singles pizzas. They are really very good. They got nice & crispy, but not hard - just as I like my pizza. The flavor is great, there are plenty of toppings. I did mine in a conventional oven, I just cannot bring myself to make a pizza in a microwave - I don't think it would have the crispy crust I love. But if that's what you like, there are microwave cooking instructions on the carton.

Helpful?3COWCM1DK5OX13610718589
Jan 20, 2026
Monica
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Perfect

This is perfect when I don't feel like cooking

Helpful?3COWCM1DK5OX13610718589