Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Luxury Premier Collection Herringbone Cozy Knit Throw for
Member's Mark Luxury Premier Collection Herringbone Cozy Knit Throw
4.8 out of 5 stars
stars
1,659 ratings655 reviews
  1. 5 stars91% (1,509)
  2. 4 stars5% (78)
  3. 3 stars1% (19)
  4. 2 stars1% (21)
  5. 1 star2% (32)

Member photos

  • +15 images
Sort by |
Showing 21-30 of 655 reviews
Jul 18, 2022
Christina O
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Soft, Comfortable & Stylish

This blanket is so, so comfy. Its soft and I'm going to say it...addicting. It really makes all my other blankets seem like burlap sacks. I was very pleasantly surprised that this is as warm as it is. I thought it was going to give minimal warmth because it's not very bulky. Wrong. I love this blanket and will be purchading more as gifts. I wish I could find these in store so I could see the colors in person, but these blankets are a true gem.

Helpful?1F4KN0WU0F2E13608908937
Feb 11, 2022
kw
5 out of 5 stars review

BAREFOOT DREAMS DUPE

This is the EXACT same blanket as the popular barefoot dreams - we have both and I honestly can’t tell the difference when we put them together. You could get four of these blankets for the same price as one of the barefoot dreams blanket. BUY IT GIFT IT

Helpful?1F4KN0WU0F2E13608908937
Nov 9, 2021
kermi
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

BEST BLANKET EVER!

The softest blanket ever! Best BFD dupe. I purchased every color of the Crafted by Catherine brand from Sams Club last year, I was obsessed with them and somehow this Member’s Mark Luxury collection is even BETTER! These are buttery soft and the coziest blanket I’ve ever felt. Ordering every color. Seriously, AMAZING!!

Helpful?1F4KN0WU0F2E13608908937
Feb 22, 2022
Melissa
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

So good, My 3rd one

This one was a gift. I originally bought myself one and I loved it so much I thought I’d get one for my mom. She thanked me multiple times after having it for a while because she had been using it so much and it was the perfect weight. She started calling it the magic blanket. This one was the 3rd one and I got it for my sister. Now everyone in her house always wants to use it.

Helpful?1F4KN0WU0F2E13608908937
Aug 9, 2022
Sylvia
5 out of 5 stars review

Very soft and cozy!!

These blankets are extremely soft and there are so many cute designs to choose from! They're also a decent size to cozy up in. I would like to compare them to the Crafted By Catherine ones so people who know what I'm talking about can decide if they want to get this Member's Mark version (Crafted By Catherine used to be the brand of these blankets at Sam's but now it's Member's Mark). I had no idea there would be a difference when I got them so maybe this will help others who are considering! The Catherine ones are a bit thicker, heavier and better in quality. These MM ones are thinner and not as heavy. However, they are just as soft. I wouldn't pass on them because of the differences but do keep in mind that they will not be the exact same. However, they're still the softest and best blankets to buy and way cheaper than Barefoot Dreams. Great affordable options! I've had no problems with snagging and mine came in the mail in a pre-sealed bag within the shipping bag. I definitely recommend these. Hope this helps!

Helpful?1F4KN0WU0F2E13608908937
Sep 5, 2022
Mark
4 out of 5 stars review

good looking soft knit blanket

Basically it's what is advertised. It's a knit looking lighter blanket, which is great in this hot weather just to cover. It is warm as well though suprisingly for a knit. I have beige and the silver gray one, they both look good, and actually not as dark as it lookis in the pictures. The blankets look more solid in the picture, but look more ribbed knit looking in real life. The problem i'm having is, i washed them twice and a ball of lint has come off each time from the lint collector in the dryer clogging it up. When i use the blanket if my clothes is even somewhat dark, there is little patches of lint on them. I willl wash them a few more times and see if the lint problem starts to go away. Otherwise, it's a comfortable lighter blanket that looks great.

Helpful?1F4KN0WU0F2E13608908937
Oct 27, 2021
Melisa
4 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Good buy

In our house we love blankets, no matter the season. This style of blanket has become popular as of late and everyone in the house fights for them. Thankfully Sam’s has them in many colors. They are super soft and not too heavy. They size is great as well, eat fit two people snuggling together during movie night. Highly recommend, also great as a gift. Comparable to a high end brand (BFD) but at a much better price point.

Helpful?1F4KN0WU0F2E13608908937
Oct 5, 2022
CHERIS
4 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Great but doesn't match

The throw is plush and beautiful, though not super soft. I am disappointed it doesn't match the pillows it was marketed with. I bought them as a matching set for a reason. So I have the throw folded inside out, because at least it's pink on the back side.

Helpful?1F4KN0WU0F2E13608908937
Nov 25, 2022
Ana
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Love it

These blankets are soooo amazingly soft! I bought one and immediately went back and bought more colors for friends as gifts for the holiday season. I will say it smelled very strongly of “warehouse” or some sort of chemical at first but I left it in the sun for a day and it went away. Definitely a good dupe for a much more expensive brand as well

Helpful?1F4KN0WU0F2E13608908937
Oct 31, 2021
Justbeautyjule
4 out of 5 stars review

Different from original Crafted by Catherine

This is a great blanket but I’m going to be super honest. I own several of the original versions of this blanket, made by Crafted by Catherine (previously sold by Sam’s Club). Recently Sam’s club rebranded the Crafted by Catherine blanket into “members mark” and the quality is not the same: it’s not as thick as original, not as fluffy and right off the bat I can tell will not stand up to as many washes as original while remaining in great shape. The original was the BEST DUPE and quality for the expensive BFD blanket and unfortunately this new version is more comparable to the other cheaper dupes I’ve seen of lesser quality. the new colors are great but I must say I’m disappointed that due to the recent success of the Crafted by Catherine blanket and Sam’s club rebranding that they have definitely gone with a much lower quality blanket (for the same price)

Helpful?1F4KN0WU0F2E13608908937