I have been using the various brands of cream that Sam's has offered over the course of 5 years and they have all been decent... until now. Sam's is now making it's own cream and so far...it is terrible. The taste is good but the consistency and the way it way it interacts with other ingredients is not great. Have to go to the other big box store to get cream now especially since it's locally made in a dairy in Texas.

I am really disappointed to find that Member's Mark Heavy Whipping Cream started putting known carcinogens and other harmful and unnecessary ingredients in their products recently (carrageenan, polysorbate 80, mono and diglycerides). They are no longer my go to for this product. I'm disappointed because it's really hard to find affordable pure products these days. I hope they go back to making it a one ingredient product again.

Have been buying this brand since they switched it for Land O Lakes and it was okay in the beginning but the last two I've purchased have been thin and watery. When you dip your finger in it has a transparency to it that true heavy cream should never have. It doesn't whip up as richly and has a lack of flavor. Will not purchase again!

Like others, I too experienced a watery substance and it did not hold body of whipped consistency for longer than an hour. And at that it didn’t have stiff peaks. I don’t even think you could make buttermilk and butter out of this stuff. That fat content isn’t enough to hold the title of “heavy” whipping cream. More like regular whipping cream with some half and half in it. Not impressed. Was really rooting for it too because of the price and MM brands are actually very good in other areas. This is not one of them that succeeded.

I love this heavy whipping cream. It has no sugar so great for me to use for my morning coffee. I whip it up and put in my coffee. I top it off with cinnamon. Awesome. Got me a small battery operated whip and like magic it whips the cream so I can heap it onto my coffee. Love waking up to have my morning coffee.

I am not sure if the ingredients or what is what makes this a fail but it doesn't work to make whipped cream, nor any hot dishes or desserts. I use this item daily and will be reinstating the other big box store membership just for this item alone. It's a fail.

I have been doing a lot of cooking classes since the inception of Covid and having to be sequestered at home. Although I don’t make a lot of heavy desserts it’s very nice to have this cream on hand not only for desserts but occasionally for savory dishes as well.

This is NOT a good product! We needed to make whipped cream for an event we were throwing. Had to make enough for 65 people. What a waste! Got 10 cartons, which should have been plenty. Unbelievable when only two came slightly close. Turned around to pipe and the bowls had collapsed into a soupy mess! We had to rush to the regular grocery store and buy Land ‘O Lakes, which is what you used to carry. So much Sadness that all that $$$$ literally went down the drain.

I tried to tell the truth about why I wouldn't recommend this whipping cream, but it my first review was rejected. So - Let's just say: I do NOT recommend this heavy whipping cream. This is NOT a heavy whipping cream consistency. This does NOT whip up as a heavy whipping cream should. This is NOT a good value. I DO NOT recommend that you buy Member's Mark Heavy Whipping Cream. This Member's Mark Heavy Whipping Cream does NOT have the sweet flavor a heavy whipping cream should have - and I would know. I am responsible for making somewhere between 25-40 desserts every Sunday for an elderly resident's family social afternoon for a large home, most of which need a good, heavy whipping cream.

I started buying this one when Sam's switched to their own brand from the Land O'Lakes one. It seemed okay at first but the last 2 I bought got extremely moldy around the lid and then traveled downward into the cream (not to mention I can't pour through the top that is all moldy). Gross! Please bring back the Land O'Lakes if the Member's Mark option cannot perform!