These were delicious. The unexpected start of the cookie lineup was the oatmeal. It wasn't too hard, it wasn't too soft, it was just right. They managed to achieve Goldilocks status with these cookies. I haven't had cookies that perfect since I was a child. My only complaint is I don't see boxes of oatmeal only cookies. Please make that happen SC.

I have bought these cookies for years but this last week the cookies were awful. Cookies were dry and hard. Processed on March 13,22. I purchased on March 14,22. Cookies tasted like they were days old. Maybe they just changed the dates on the old cookies to look like a new batch. I will buy again because maybe it was a onetime bad batch, but if the next batch I buy taste like these cookies did i will definitely return them to the store.

Sam’s has finally perfected these cookies!!! Absolute bangers! Love them!

Hard

tasteless

Great cookies

These were some of the nastiest cookies, definitely not fresh!

I've been buying those delicious soft and chewy cookies for years. The last ones I bought were terrible. They were hard and stale, which I returned. I bought another package of cookies, which were just as bad.

These cookies were fresh but they have a strange flavor. All 3 kinds tasted off to us. We brought them to a pot luck and nobody ate them. If you’re looking for traditional flavors, these aren’t it.

We bought these the other day. The ones I had were just right. I like a softer cookie and this did it. I will buy again. So good I didn't want to share with my boyfriend.