I agree, they don't fit the same, smaller for sure. Perhaps the blend has changed and they shrink a bit more after the first wash and dry. Nevertheless, they are definitely a different fit.

These shirts are far inferior quality! After a few washes they "pill" and become coarse and uncomfortable. The Eddie Bauer were the same blend and also from Pakistan!! What the heck did you change!!!??

These r-shirts are inferior in quality to the Eddie Bauer t-shirts! They wear out very quickly and are nothing like the Eddie Bauer t-shirts that I have grown to love.

Another outstanding Members Mark from Sam's!! Love all of your Members Mark products that you provide for us to save money!! I always size up 1 size because my husband likes them loose fitting.

These tshirts replaced the Eddie Bauer shirts and they are inferior. They are thin and wear out quickly. Eddie Bauer tshirts were of much better quality.

my daughter is on the spectrum and has a thing with clothes materials. it's hard to find her shirts because they aren't comfy enough or bug her. We've found that thrift store shirts are perfect for her because they've usually been washed many times and worn in. Got her one of these to try for PE, and when I got home from work I was greeted with "WHERE DID YOU GET MY PE SHIRT FROM!!??" "I need many more please, they're perfectly perfect." So now I've got 6 more in my cart to order. They're very soft and not too thick, not too thin. Give them a try.

These shirts used to be my go to for using with my Cricut. They were a super soft, lightweight material, and fit very well. Then they disappeared from clubs for a year or two and when I discovered they were back, I was very excited. But that excitement quickly gave way to disappointment when I learned that they no longer feel as soft or as lightweight AND the cut/sizing has changed, I held up one of the new shirts to one of the old ones that had never been washed, and the new version was at least 2” smaller around the waist and therefore doesn't fit me like the old ones did. Very disappointed in the fact that this new version is being sold in the same listing as the old one, with all the positive reviews from the old version.

Perfect is just what i nees

Great product so inexpensive

Great Shirts, Last a while, Soft and nice to wear