Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Stearns & Foster Estate Tight Top Mattress Set (Available in Soft, Firm, and Ultra Firm) for
Stearns & Foster Estate Tight Top Mattress Set (Available in Soft, Firm, and Ultra Firm)
4.2 out of 5 stars
stars
336 ratings336 reviews
  1. 5 stars74% (247)
  2. 4 stars7% (22)
  3. 3 stars2% (8)
  4. 2 stars6% (20)
  5. 1 star12% (39)
Sort by |
Showing 101-110 of 336 reviews
May 23, 2026
RP
5 out of 5 stars review

Best, quiet sleep in 4 years

My husband severally broke his neck four years ago. After several surgeries, metal plates, brackets and screws he can only sleep flat on his back, all night, every night! And every night he would snore, very loudly. I ended up sleeping in another room. The first night on our new StearnsandFoster bed I was able to sleep the entire night with him. He didn't snore! The second night his snoring was the quiet breathing I was used to hearing for the 53 years we've been married. Thank you for the support we both needed for a good nights sleep.

Review from Stearns & Foster
Helpful?26AEPF4HW7WP13599871338
Apr 16, 2026
Janiels
1 out of 5 stars review

Too Hard with Body Wells Hard to Sleep

We purchased the Estate medium firm which we tested in the store. This is our third Sterns and Foster mattress but this new design is awful. As soon as it arrived we called the store thinking, despite the label, they had sent us the firm in error as the bed was very hard. We were told it needed time for the top to release. It's now been just over a year, it is still very hard and has developed deep body wells and I now have spinal back pain. We rotate this mattress monthly and even rotate a quarter turn sleeping on it cross-wise. We have had an expert inspect it and the result is the wear is “normal” so there is nothing we can do. We are looking for alternatives and will need to donate a near-brand-new mattress to find comfort. We are so disappointed.

Review from Stearns & Foster
Helpful?26AEPF4HW7WP13599871338
May 9, 2026
kellys
5 out of 5 stars review

Not a waterbed but

I recently circle back to the Stearns & Foster after having one while married for 20 years (yes I know too long, 15 was probably long enough for the mattress and marriage but here we are😊). Treated myself to a new S&F because I needed it and deserved one which really is ok to say, already adjusting to sleeping more than a couple hours a night. While it's not the freeflow waterbed of the 80s from my younger days it's the next best step to getting a good nights rest. Highly recommend to all my fellow Gen Xers.

Review from ashleyfurniture
Helpful?26AEPF4HW7WP13599871338
May 18, 2026
Happy Sleeper
5 out of 5 stars review

we found the one

We love this mattress. After changing 3 different mattresses we finally found the one that we can sleep without waking up in pain. We have the soft tight top. I am really surprised this is the definition of soft, but the mattress feels really comfortable yet very stable.

Review from Stearns & Foster
Helpful?26AEPF4HW7WP13599871338
May 16, 2026
Val
3 out of 5 stars review

Not the correct size

This mattress is very comfortable. The problem I have is it is supposed to be to be 16”. I bought sheets for this. They did not fit properly. I have since discovered the bed is actually 14”. I feel cheated because it is not what it was suppose to be. I could understand if it was 1/4” off, but not 2”. Which makes me say don't trust Stearns and Foster!

Review from Stearns & Foster
Helpful?26AEPF4HW7WP13599871338
Jun 5, 2026
Exceptional Estate Firm
5 out of 5 stars review

Estate Firm

Simply the best! We decided to replace our mattress after 8 years. The quality is exceptional. With having lower back surgery, this product has made a difference. Thanks again Sterns and Foster for the quality!

Review from Stearns & Foster
Helpful?26AEPF4HW7WP13599871338
Jun 1, 2026
ROSETTEL
5 out of 5 stars review

Great mattress purchase

This is an awesome mattress! It's firm but comfortable at the same time. This is a replacement mattress that Ashley very kindly agreed to make and I couldn't be happier with the store and my purchase.

Review from ashleyfurniture
Helpful?26AEPF4HW7WP13599871338
Jun 11, 2026
Kim
5 out of 5 stars review

Great

The first night on a new mattress is always a little odd. I was pleasantly surprised. I fell asleep fast and had significantly less pain upon arising. That's only night one. Can't wait to go back to bed tonight!

Review from Stearns & Foster
Helpful?26AEPF4HW7WP13599871338
Mar 15, 2026
Amy
1 out of 5 stars review

Poor warranty service.

I’ve owned my mattress for less than two years and it has a small hole from the material unraveling. They said it is cosmetic and is not covered under the warranty. How could a mattress less than two years spring a hole. I’ve owned many mattresses and this has never happened. This is not a cosmetic issue, it is a manufacturer issue and they could care less to try and resolve the matter.

Review from Stearns & Foster
Helpful?26AEPF4HW7WP13599871338
Feb 2, 2026
not pleased
3 out of 5 stars review

Solid, extremely heavy.

I wish I knew how heavy this mattress was going to be, we have a difficult time tucking in the sheets and blanket. Our old mattress did not sag in the middle, I have to work myself to the side with this one. I also wake up in the middle of the night now since we bought this mattress with pain in my hands, I've tried changing pillows but it doesn't make a difference. Turning the mattress is a real chore. I did not read reviews before buying.

Review from Stearns & Foster
Helpful?26AEPF4HW7WP13599871338