Like some of the other reviewers, I had 1 apple that was rotten out of 8 that were in the bag. Four pounds of these large apples were $1.28 each, not counting the one I threw away. They were covered in juice from the bad apple, so I rinsed them off. There was no unpleasant odor. However, these apples were the best apple my husband and I have ever eaten! The flavor is wonderful. Get a napkin before you eat one because of their juiciness. You'll need it. I can't wait to make a pie with them.

I thought Honey Crisp were the BEST.. now COSMIC apples has moved to first place. From the first bite of the sweetest, crisp apple You’ll be hooked. Forget about needing a piece of chocolate - this is 10x better. They can even be stored for 10-12 months in the fridge. Go head.. take a bite! I promise they become your #1 too!! Thank you, WASHINGTON STATE UNIVERSITY!

I never did care much for apples.. but now I do!! These are so juicy and sweet.

Not sure if it fake but it felt weird 😕 didn't rot

These are bomb apples!! The kids loved them! They have the most unique taste.

I’m an Apple snob, I cannot stand apples that not crisp, too sweet. These have the perfect texture, phenomenal. The other Apple that similar to these are Pink Lady apples. I’d recommend these to anyone

I was excited to try after reading the review. We bought a bushel of Evercrisp in the mountains and they were hands down the BEST apples we’ve ever had. Crispy with a great snap in the bite, no mealy texture at all and so sweet and juicy. It was honestly like biting into Apple cider lol. Anyways saw these at Sams and decided to try them. They’re just ok, a bit mealy/grainy and more of a bland tart than sweet. I won’t buy again. Prefer Fuji or envy over these. They actually remind me a bit in flavor of a pink lady.

Usually Cosmic apples are very good, however, this bag must be very old. Red coloring from skin leached throughout apple - assume it was some kind of coating...Apples also soft, not crisp. Cut open 4 before I trashed whole bag. Very disappointing.

I got home and the bag had 3 rotten apples (bag was leaking) and out of the rest I could save 2. The apple skins have a waxy substance, tried to clean - no good. I really wanted to try these apples - next time I’ll check the bag or get them from the club and not pickup.

Half the bag was rotten not sure how many are suppose to come in the bag but we only got 8 and 5 out the 8 were rotten. First time ordering apples from there and a new brand of apples too try and we will not be doing this again. 8.00$ and only 3 apples out of 8 were good. Hopefully I can get a refund