Unfortunately these festive cookie flavors are odd and we had a ton left over from a party. I would not buy them again. I wish I had bought the original cookie tray that everyone always loves. I learned my lesson. I would skip these and buy any other Sams cookies.

I was so excited for these cookies, with the different flavors and all, but they turned out to be slightly underbaked. I know some people like that... not golden on the bottom and a bit gooey in the middle, but I do not. Would prefer fully cooked cookies.

Bought these last weekend. I was very disappointed. The regular cookie trays are good, but these holiday flavors were horrible. The peanut butter were the only ones that were tolerable, and even they were not great. They appeared to be chocolate chunk with peanut butter chips, but you couldnt taste any chocolate at all. All the others (as delicious as they sounded and looked) had very weird artificial flavoring. My kids wouldn't eat them either. Do not recommend.

High in cholesterol

good

These are good, but samsclub needs to bring back the previous tray of cookies, they were much better

I just bought these today, 12/21. Packed 12/20 with best by date 12/25. I only ate the turtle brownie and butterscotch pecan so far. Both were moist and delicious.

If you're wondering how this variety of cookies taste, let me tell you. I received compliments all night after bringing these cookies to work. Each one was very good and flavorful. My personal favorite was the pecan pie.

I would not recommend this cookie tray I would have been further ahead to just buy some slice and baked cookies from the supermarket totally tasteless waste of money.

The pecan pie were a bit bland and the brown butter shortbread were awful. Everyone that picked that one up and tasted it was throwing it away.