I only noticed these in our Sam's recently and decided to gamble on them even though we generally are not big fans of "cookies and cream" or "chocolate chip cookie dough" flavors. We were pleasantly surprise to find we like these as a chocolate flavor much better than the official chocolate flavor. If you are just kind of OK with the regular chocolate, try these. You might like them better as we do.

I've been a fan of these products for many, many years. I was expecting so much more from the Cookies & Cream variety. Unfortunately, the bitter after taste & total lack of flavor 😕 means the bitter end of this flavor for me. I'll stick with the Chocolate 🍫 Peanut 🥜 Butter 🧈 for the time being.

I am convinced that I received a bad batch. The flavor was horrible and the consistency was oddly thick compared to the other flavors. It was not even expired! I was so grossed out that I ended up throwing all of them away. I will definitely never buy again.

This is THE reason I renew my Sam’s club membership! PLEASE BRING IT BACK. I’ve lost 75 pounds and this played a huge part in my coffee routine, and Walmart’s prices are 5$ more for the same product amount! Please bring back! the best flavor! The chocolate is too much, but the COOKIES AND CREAM IS LIFE. I have many friends and family members devistated that they don’t carry this flavor.

I’ve had these before and they were sooo good. I was excited to see them in stock again but something about this batch ain’t right. Like others have said, there is a super weird chemical taste to them. The actual cookies and cream flavor is so good so I’m not sure what happened here. I just chug it after a workout to make it go down as fast as possible. So sad!

I don't think you ever really fall in love with the shakes. But I find that this flavor is one of the most one of the easiest to tolerate. Best of all I have seen an improvement in my muscle tone and strength since I've started drinking these. My nails and hair also seem to be benefiting from the additional protein

This flavor is my new favorite shake! The taste is meu flavorful for low calories. It doesn't leave an after taste like the chocolate flavor does. My only problem is Sam's Club doesn't ever have it available for purchase. Please fix it so that consumers like myself can purchase this product.

Don’t like the taste

The worst one yet! Too artificial, it doesn't taste like cookies and cream!

This is by far the worst PP shake flavor I've had. It tastes chemical-y. I'll stick with the regular chocolate flavor.