Hi JP, thank you for taking the time to share your experience about our Bourbon Peach and Honey Hot Wing Sauce 2-pack. We're sorry to hear that had two of the same flavor in your item, as you're right, you should have had one of each. We'd be happy to replace the product so you can try both flavors. Please reach out to us directly via this link https://kinders.com/contact-us/ and provide your contact details so we can get this out to you!