Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Premium Beef Curated Box, Frozen, 9 lbs. for
Member's Mark Premium Beef Curated Box, Frozen, 9 lbs.

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 21-30 of 42 reviews
Oct 25, 2024
Alex F
1 out of 5 stars review

Spoiled mystery box

I wanted to like this product, I had big plans to purchase a box every month when I found out it existed. BUT.... it was missing one of the most expensive cuts of meat for starters. I expressed the situation to support and they partially refunded me which was nice (I appreciate that). But then it gets worse, and I wont even bother complaining or starting another case but every package that I have opened has been browned and smells awful, the meat is gross and almost spoiled. There is an air leak or a cut in every single bag, I haven't had a single bag that was fully intact and still sealed. When it thaws there is blood all over my refrigerator. The ground beef was especially disgusting. It is a great concept and I hope people have better luck than I did. It felt like I just got a bunch of left over. misfits/ damaged items that they couldn't sell in a mystery box. Very sad :( I will mention that the package did great with shipping, everything was still totally frozen when I got it.

Helpful?6WXA3G7ZSS0X13589500023
Nov 24, 2025
JLynn
2 out of 5 stars review

Delivery %26 Amount received

My rating is based on the delivery and amount received. FedEx driver leaves the box in the sun (temp 80 today) at the top of the driveway by the mailbox. Also, easy for anyone to drive by and pick up from the ground. Did not set at front door in the shade. The dry ice packed inside the box was gone. However, the meat was still frozen. If you order, I would make sure it's cold outside or be at home when it delivers. I happened to be off work when the box was delivered. Received 8 items in the box, total ounces marked was 96 oz. 9lbs should be 144 oz. I'm hopeful the product taste really good.

Helpful?6WXA3G7ZSS0X13589500023
Feb 18, 2023
OvO
3 out of 5 stars review

Not very impressed

Just had the top sirloin with another one I bought in store. Both are member's mark prime and are cooked exactly the same way. The one I got from the store tastes more tender and apparently has much more marbling. The delivered one is more chewy and less juicy. I think I'll stick with buying meat from Sam's directly instead of having it delivered from now on.

Helpful?6WXA3G7ZSS0X13589500023
Jul 12, 2022
Debbie
2 out of 5 stars review

Thawed out!

I received the package from FedEx on the date is was supposed to arrive, which was great. However, when I I opened the box the meat was almost completely thawed out and some of it was leaking bloody liquid into and all over the box! Yuck!! I washed the individual packages to get the sticky stuff off and then used my Foodsaver to wrap and seal them before putting the thawed meat in my freezer. Then I called the meat market at Sam’s to explain the situation and was told the meat was probably okay.

Helpful?6WXA3G7ZSS0X13589500023
Aug 2, 2022
NanaLikesIt
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Good Deal During This Period of High Meat Costs

This box of meat put a smile on hubbie's face AND tummy!

Helpful?6WXA3G7ZSS0X13589500023
Jun 18, 2022
dmv777
5 out of 5 stars review

Meat Box ( The Field )

This was a very nice Premium Meat Box, packaged well, came in as noted, and ALL the items included in it were well worth the price. So glad, I was able to purchase and receive this quality meat box.

Helpful?6WXA3G7ZSS0X13589500023
Nov 17, 2022
Terry9297
2 out of 5 stars review

Expensive- only one beef

These seem to be really high price since it is ONE grass fed beef and the rest is regular chicken--and of the meat a whole chicken is certainly not worth $14/pound unless it is organic, which this is not.

Helpful?6WXA3G7ZSS0X13589500023
Jul 16, 2022
MJ
5 out of 5 stars review

Worth every penny

I've never been able to buy a steak and cook it like a restaurant. So imagine my surprise when I cooked two of these and they were better than a restaurant. Can't wait to make hamburgers. I will be restocking with these on a regular bases.

Helpful?6WXA3G7ZSS0X13589500023
Aug 1, 2024
Sk
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Perfect bundle for the busy working mom.

Best purchase! Best Value! this is the way to purchase, perfect packaged and delivered right to my door when I wanted it. All I had to do was put it straight in the freezer.

Helpful?6WXA3G7ZSS0X13589500023
Nov 9, 2022
David
4 out of 5 stars review

Nice but not as good as should be

It arrived in good condition but not high quality. was good for supplementing my groceries. Had a couple of steaks that weren't sealed well and leaked while defrosting.

Helpful?6WXA3G7ZSS0X13589500023