So glad Sam's brought back their Fresh Salsa. The replacement was not near as good. We pick up a jar after a long hiatus, and the family just about gobbled up the whole jar in one sitting. Best fresh salsa we've found, please do not discontinue again.

This used to be good. This time it has a weird texture like a thickening agent has been added. Strange taste. It has waaay too many onions. Will not purchase again. I spooned some in a single serve bowl and couldn't even eat it. My husband said he didn't like it either. Trash. Waste.

I have always been disappointed when I try to replace my homemade salsa with packaged but I was tired and thought this looked “real” because I could actually see the onions and chopped tomatoes and the ingredient list was short. It was WONDERFUL and good enough to serve guests. Unfortunately, just one week later it was gone. I’m hoping the management has enough sense to keep it stocked from now on. Oh, and it was great with the roasted chicken and low carb tortillas I also picked up.

This was very thin, watery, and not much taste. The brand Sam's use to Carry was MUCH better. Seems like the Sam's brand in many products don't measure up. Won't be buying it again, in fact, I try to stay away from most Sam's brands now....if there is a choice. And the items to choose from are getting less. Not a good move.

This used to be my favorite salsa. I'm not sure if they bought out Italian Rose Salsa or just followed the pattern but this tastes like smashed tomatoes with no other flavors. I see all the other cilantro and garlic but they somehow have no presence in the taste.

This used to be my favorite salsa, I would go through at least a jar every week. It used to be mild like the bottle says but now it’s sooo HOT! I can’t eat it, my mouth feels like it’s on fire. I have tried my 4th bottle in the last few months hoping it was just a fluke. It’s NOT. PLEASE make this salsa mild again. Did the recipe change? If so, please go back to the old recipe! Please make it mild like the bottle says.

Personally I believe it is the best "fresh" Salsa on the market. My family won't use any other salsa....and they use it on everything....or just by itself with chips or pretzel chips. It's just great. PLEASE DON'T STOP SELLING THIS.....we seem to go through 2-3 jars every month.

I love a good cilantro salsa... this is NOT a good cilantro salsa. I'm thinking it was the type of tomatoes they used. Flavorless. Also quite onion-y. Otherwise if you cook with it, you might be able to help it. Didn't get that far. It has a fresh 'feel' to it like Pico de Gallo, but not. Lots of juice.

This salsa has an odd aroma and an equally odd taste. I am very fond of fresh cilantro.I use fresh cilantro in my omelette, daily. I'm not sure why this salsa smells and tastes this way. I will not buy it again. I may throw it out and accept the loss

Being tired of the bottles of salsa that taste like ketchup with onions, I decided to look for a fresh salsa. I bought this salsa not noticing that it was the Cilantro version. The fresh salsa is nice, tastes fine, and is a great value. Be aware that there are two versions of Member's Mark Fresh Salsa - one regular, one with Cilantro. I don't care much for Cilantro - having said that, the salsa is alright. Next time I'll get the "regular" version of Sam's Salsa as this one is fresh and good albeit with cilantro. If you enjoy the taste of fresh salsa and like cilantro - you will enjoy this fine salsa. If not, try the regular version!