Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Pop-Tarts Toaster Pastries, Frosted Strawberry, 48 ct. for
Pop-Tarts Toaster Pastries, Frosted Strawberry, 48 ct.
4.7 out of 5 stars
stars
1,709 ratings394 reviews
  1. 5 stars85% (1,449)
  2. 4 stars9% (149)
  3. 3 stars3% (51)
  4. 2 stars1% (22)
  5. 1 star2% (38)
Sort by |
Showing 251-260 of 394 reviews
Jun 4, 2020
birdermom
2 out of 5 stars review

They get stuck in the toaster every time

The taste is fine, but they get stuck in the toaster every time. I believe they got a lot thinner over the years. As they heat, they bend between the elements, resulting in a burning, crumbly mess. Have tried in two different model toasters with the same results. Will not be purchasing again.

Review from kelloggs.com
Helpful?0WTW7GEQ4RIL13589209293
Oct 25, 2020
Sooz
3 out of 5 stars review

Disappointed

I hadn't had one of these in years and was looking forward to it. Upon opening the box, I could see that one package was different from the others. It actually contained one and a half Pop-Tarts instead of two. Seriously. They tasted a bit stale too.

Review from kelloggs.com
Helpful?0WTW7GEQ4RIL13589209293
Jun 8, 2020
Mommytrex
5 out of 5 stars review

Yummy!

I bought this to add zest to my mid morning snack time. Unfrosted Strawberry was my 1st Pop tart that I had at 11 or 12 years old. It's always been my favorite. It tastes good even when you burn it a bit because you popped the Pop tarts back down in the toaster for a 2nd time.

Review from kelloggs.com
Helpful?0WTW7GEQ4RIL13589209293
Mar 17, 2021
Catz
5 out of 5 stars review

Sweet but not too sweet

Unfrosted strawberry Pop-Tarts is something I always make sure is in my pantry my grandson and I both love the strawberry flavor and not having frosting on top kind of makes it more like you're eating a pastry versus a desert. I just wish they would stop decrease in the size and add a little more filling to the pastry but I still enjoy the pastries just the same

Review from kelloggs.com
Helpful?0WTW7GEQ4RIL13589209293
Dec 4, 2023
fefef
1 out of 5 stars review

A Culinary Misstep: The Unpalatable Tale of the S

Introduction: In the vast world of snack foods, Pop-Tarts have secured their place as a beloved and nostalgic treat for many. With a wide array of flavors that cater to various taste preferences, it's surprising when a new addition to the lineup falls short of expectations. Unfortunately, the Stanberry flavor of Pop-Tart is a prime example of a culinary misstep, leaving consumers with a distinctly unsatisfying experience. Body: Firstly, the name itself is a curious amalgamation of strawberry and an elusive mystery component. The expectation of a delightful fusion is quickly shattered upon the first bite. One would anticipate the sweet, succulent taste of ripe strawberries, but instead, the Stanberry flavor introduces a confusing and disconcerting blend that fails to capture the essence of either fruit. One of the most glaring issues with the Stanberry Pop-Tart is the artificial and overpowering sweetness that assaults the taste buds. Unlike other Pop-Tart flavors that strike a balance between sugary goodness and the natural flavors of the ingredients, Stanberry seems to rely on an excessive amount of artificial sweeteners, leaving a cloying aftertaste that lingers unpleasantly. This heavy-handed approach to sweetness not only masks any potential hint of real fruit flavor but also makes the overall eating experience overwhelmingly saccharine. Furthermore, the texture of the Stanberry filling is a departure from the luscious, jam-like consistency found in other fruit-flavored Pop-Tarts. Instead, it presents an oddly gelatinous and dense center that lacks the juicy burst expected from a fruit-filled pastry. The absence of a satisfying texture diminishes the enjoyment of the Pop-Tart, leaving consumers yearning for the familiar and delightful bite that other flavors provide. A critical aspect of any successful snack is its ability to evoke a sensory experience that resonates positively with consumers. Unfortunately, the Stanberry Pop-Tart falls short in this regard, as its peculiar flavor profile fails to evoke the warm, comforting feelings associated with the classic pastry. Instead of triggering fond memories or satisfying cravings, the Stanberry variant leaves consumers perplexed and disappointed, questioning the decision-making behind its creation. Conclusion: In the grand tapestry of Pop-Tart flavors, the Stanberry iteration stands out as a regrettable misstep. Its artificial sweetness, lackluster texture, and failure to capture the essence of its purported strawberry inspiration make it an unappealing choice for even the most adventurous snack enthusiasts. While Pop-Tart aficionados may continue to explore the myriad flavors offered by this iconic brand, it's safe to say that the Stanberry variant is best left untouched, allowing room for the more successful and delectable options within the Pop-Tart repertoire.

Review from kelloggs.com
Helpful?0WTW7GEQ4RIL13589209293
Apr 22, 2024
Tartmuncher 42
1 out of 5 stars review

They Ruined my life

It was a cool autumn morning, the leaves turning brilliant shades of red and gold as my wife and I sat down for breakfast. We had been married for 12 years, and our morning routine had become a comforting ritual of coffee, toast, and conversation. But on this particular morning, something was different. I reached into the pantry and pulled out a box of unfrosted strawberry pop-tarts, a treat that we hadn't had in years. As I placed the pop-tarts in the toaster, a wave of nostalgia washed over me. I remembered the days when we were first married, young and carefree, living in a tiny apartment and struggling to make ends meet. Back then, a box of pop-tarts was a luxury, a special treat that we would indulge in on lazy Sunday mornings before heading out for a long hike in the mountains. But as I watched the pop-tarts pop up from the toaster, my wife's face darkened. She picked up one of the pastries, examining it with a critical eye. "Unfrosted?" she said, her voice tinged with disappointment. "I thought we were past this." I was taken aback by her reaction. I had picked out the unfrosted pop-tarts as a way to mix things up, to inject a little bit of spontaneity into our morning routine. But my wife seemed to view it as a betrayal of our shared history, a rejection of the traditions that had shaped our relationship. Over the next few days, the tension between us grew. My wife's disappointment in the unfrosted pop-tarts seemed to loom over us like a dark cloud, poisoning the easy camaraderie that we had once shared. We bickered over small things, like who forgot to take out the trash or whose turn it was to do the dishes. Our conversations became strained, the easy laughter that used to flow between us now replaced by awkward silences. I tried to talk to my wife about what was happening, about how something as trivial as a box of pop-tarts could be driving us apart. But she was distant, her eyes focused on something far away. It was as if the unfrosted pop-tarts had become a symbol of all the ways in which we had grown apart over the years, of all the compromises we had made and the sacrifices we had endured. And then, one day, my wife dropped a bombshell. She told me that she was thinking of leaving, of walking away from our marriage and starting fresh. I was stunned, my heart breaking at the thought of losing the person I had built my life around. I pleaded with her to reconsider, to give us another chance. But she was resolute, her mind made up. As she packed her bags and walked out the door, I sat alone in our empty house, the unfrosted pop-tarts sitting on the kitchen counter like a bitter reminder of all that had gone wrong. In the weeks and months that followed, I tried to make sense of what had happened, to understand how something as small and insignificant as a box of pop-tarts could have the power to destroy a relationship that had once seemed unbreakable. And slowly, painfully, I came to realize that it wasn't the pop-tarts themselves that had ruined my marriage. It was the years of neglect, the unspoken resentments, the missed opportunities for connection and understanding. The pop-tarts were just a symptom of a much deeper problem, a sign that we had lost sight of the things that had once brought us together. In the end, I knew that I would never be able to look at a box of unfrosted strawberry pop-tarts without feeling a pang of regret, a twinge of sadness for all that we had lost. But I also knew that I would carry those memories with me, a reminder of the love that had once been between us, a testament to the fragility and resilience of the human heart. And as I watched the leaves fall from the trees outside my window, I made a silent vow to myself: to never let something as small and insignificant as a pop-tart come between me and the person I loved ever again.

Review from kelloggs.com
Helpful?0WTW7GEQ4RIL13589209293
Jul 19, 2024
Skugge
1 out of 5 stars review

Horrible

It's been years since I have had these favorites of mine, so I bought some two days ago upon getting home I opened a package up. I was disappointed when I bit into it, the crust was bland and crumbly it has the flavor of what I can only imagine cardboard would taste like. The filling was / is more disappointing than the crust is, I couldn't taste anything that resembled strawberries, for that fact I couldn't even tell there was even a filling inside this pathetic piece of cardboard tasting crust. I ate both of the Pop tarts hoping that the strawberry filling might have been uneven inside this catastrophic failure of a pastry. Without a doubt strawberry Pop tarts are as bad as spoiled milk is. I will never buy anything from this company again nor allow anyone to bring these failures of a so called food item in my house ever again. I can only imagine how bad the frosted pop tarts are. I WILL NOT RECOMMEND THESE FOR CONSUMPTION TO ANY LIVING CREATURE AT ANYTIME.

Review from kelloggs.com
Helpful?0WTW7GEQ4RIL13589209293
Sep 24, 2025
Marq5
5 out of 5 stars review

Warm Treat

Morning treat provides needed boost to start my day!

Review from kelloggs.com
Helpful?0WTW7GEQ4RIL13589209293
Sep 24, 2025
Don
4 out of 5 stars review

A go to flavor

Product needs more filling and moisture but it's a flavor to stay

Review from kelloggs.com
Helpful?0WTW7GEQ4RIL13589209293
Aug 15, 2020
angelmikie
4 out of 5 stars review

poptarts unfrosted strawberry

I have never liked toasting my poptarts and I never really liked the frosted. I like the strawberry unfrosted but I really wish they would have unfrosted Cherry

Review from kelloggs.com
Helpful?0WTW7GEQ4RIL13589209293