This does not taste like a peanut butter cup. It has a strange taste to it. While I can tell they were shooting for peanut butter this flavor fails in comparison to their other flavors. I really love chocolate and peanut butter and was looking forward to this one, but it just has too much of a fake taste.

First let me say I love premier protein shakes. Caramel, chocolate, vanilla, latte.. all very good flavors. This flavor, however, I can only compare to that of a peanut butter cup that survived multiple Halloweens before being eaten by an unfortunate candy seeker. Go with the caramel. It's much much better.

The chocolate peanut butter protein shake tastes very chalky and gritty to me. The peanut butter wasn't a 'good' peanut butter flavor, and it really overpowered the chocolate, imo. My favorites so far are the 1) Cake Batter (unbelievably good with MINIMAL 'protein shake' aftertaste) 2) Banana Cream (subtle, but tasty) and 3) Cafe Latte (love the caffeine content). I hope and pray my husband likes the chocolate peanut butter, because otherwise that's $26 down the drain!

Total CRAP. Tastes like a bunch of awful fake chemicals. Unfortunately bought an entire case and I'm on travel & brought some with me so not sure I can return the case, which I don't want to drink. Chocolate, vanilla are okay but rather sweet. Cafe latte is okay but rather strong with caffeine in it. This chocolate peanut flavor you couldn't give to me for free.

I saw the announcement that they were coming out with this flavor so I was super excited when I saw that Sam's was going to have it. I opened my box of them as soon as they arrived and had one for breakfast the next morning. I am hooked! I am not a fan of the chocolate premier shake but this one is creamy and the peanut butter definitely shines through. Only upset that they are out of stock so I cant order more at this time but I will be checking back daily. I hope this will be a permanent addition. Soooo good!

I liked it better than the regular chocolate

It's amazing! Best shake on the market 🫱🏿‍🫲🏾

It’s a smooth drink with my favorite flavors combined

This is the best one then Carmel

I buy these all the time, they taste just like a Reese's Peanut butter cup.