I’m making my way through the A and Premier Protein shakes to see which ones are the best. When I first purchased the PB cup PP shakes, I had high hopes— who doesn’t love Reese’s?! Unfortunately, they fell a little flat. Pros: This shake kept me the fullest of all the A and other PP shakes I have had to date. I easily went from my 12:30 lunch to not eating dinner until 6+ hours later with no problem. There was no grittiness with this one and it had a nice, thicker mouth feel when compared to other shakes I’ve tried (similar to the A dark chocolate royale). The PB flavor was on point and made me wish they’d start a PB Premier Protein shake *hint hint*... Cons: The SF aftertaste was stronger with this one than some of the other PP and A shakes I’ve had. It wasn’t as bad as some of the coffee ones by any means (most of these were garbage), but it was enough that I tended to chug it versus sip it through my lunch break. The chocolate was very up front and in your face. It was also overridden by the PB flavor (aka: the blending of chocolate and PB you hoped for didn’t happen— think dollar store peanut butter cups instead of happy Reese bliss) Overall, would I order this one again? Maybe, but there are much better options out there from PP and A if you’re looking for a chocolate shake that meets all the parameters of a diet shake.

This protein shake is not very tasty. I was so excited to try it since the chocolate one is really good so when I heard peanut butter & chocolate I had to get it. Boy was I disappointed! It tastes nothing like a peanut butter cup as others said. I can't even explain the taste except it wasn't good and the after taste was even worse. Do not waste your money....

Total CRAP. Tastes like a bunch of awful fake chemicals. Unfortunately bought an entire case and I'm on travel & brought some with me so not sure I can return the case, which I don't want to drink. Chocolate, vanilla are okay but rather sweet. Cafe latte is okay but rather strong with caffeine in it. This chocolate peanut flavor you couldn't give to me for free.

First let me say I love premier protein shakes. Caramel, chocolate, vanilla, latte.. all very good flavors. This flavor, however, I can only compare to that of a peanut butter cup that survived multiple Halloweens before being eaten by an unfortunate candy seeker. Go with the caramel. It's much much better.

I saw the announcement that they were coming out with this flavor so I was super excited when I saw that Sam's was going to have it. I opened my box of them as soon as they arrived and had one for breakfast the next morning. I am hooked! I am not a fan of the chocolate premier shake but this one is creamy and the peanut butter definitely shines through. Only upset that they are out of stock so I cant order more at this time but I will be checking back daily. I hope this will be a permanent addition. Soooo good!

This is the best premier protein shake, hands down. The negative reviews are because people expect a protein shake to taste like a milkshake. This is still a protein shake at the end of the day and won’t taste exactly like chocolate peanut butter. It doesn’t taste like the chocolate flavor. There’s a subtle taste of peanut butter, but it’s just right. You have to try but of course everyone’s taste buds are different.

Way too sweet tasting, didn’t agree with me.

I love most premier flavors but this is the best one yet!!!!!

Addictive. Absolutely delicious over ice.

This is a definitel "No" for me