Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Comfort Pro Anti-Fatigue Kitchen Mat, 20" x 39", Assorted Designs for
Member's Mark Comfort Pro Anti-Fatigue Kitchen Mat, 20" x 39", Assorted Designs
4.7 out of 5 stars
stars1,779 ratings748 reviews
  1. 5 stars86% (1,532)
  2. 4 stars7% (133)
  3. 3 stars3% (47)
  4. 2 stars1% (17)
  5. 1 star3% (50)

Member photos

  • +103 images
Sort by |
Showing 171-180 of 748 reviews
Feb 4, 2022
Lisa
4 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Love it /Odd color

Love the thickness but wish they had a few more colors in stock, would give it a 5*if so. I ordered what was called a blue but it's as purple as a sunset!

Helpful?27URMA7BSBEN13585924599
Dec 16, 2021
Jason
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Thick and cushiony

Very comfortable to stand on in bare feet. You notice the stain relief immediately when you step on it. One in front of the sink and one in front of the stove. The edges are beveled nicely.

Helpful?27URMA7BSBEN13585924599
May 21, 2023
Joey W
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Great Big Mat, Even better price

Great quality for the price. Our other kitchen mat would slide around and with the name brand of it, you would have thought it would have stayed in one place. Also this thing is massive. Love the color and pattern options.

Helpful?27URMA7BSBEN13585924599
Apr 14, 2026
ELAINE
1 out of 5 stars review

Not for high traffic area

Looks nice, but is very difficult to clean. In fact I haven’t figured out how to clean it. You cannot wet it because it soaks up the water and takes too long to dry. It stains easily. In a high traffic area like the kitchen it is a very bad choice.

Helpful?27URMA7BSBEN13585924599
Jul 2, 2024
tp
1 out of 5 stars review

photos do not match received mat

I tried to get a matching small and large mat for my kitchen based on the photos available and they've sent me the wrong small mat three times now. The screenshot is the mat I tried to get and the photo is the mat I received multiple times. Even after completely returning the order and starting over. Now I can't even return the large mat so I'm stuck with two mismatched mats which was what I was trying to replace to begin with.

Helpful?27URMA7BSBEN13585924599
Aug 23, 2024
Maggie S
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Comfortable

Helpful?27URMA7BSBEN13585924599
Jan 13, 2026
GrandmaS
1 out of 5 stars review

Nice mat but didn't last

I really liked the kitchen mat. It made standing to cook very comfortable. The reason for the bad review is I picked up the mat to wipe it like I have done every week when I clean the floor but this time it was stuck to the floor and a piece peeled off and stuck to the floor. See photo below. Photo won't attach network error

Helpful?27URMA7BSBEN13585924599
Dec 31, 2025
JES
1 out of 5 stars review

Not Same Quality As Used To Be

We've purchased these Member's Mark anti fatigue mats previously %26 really like them. Needed to replace due to normal wear %26 tear (had for long time - high traffic area in kitchen). Ordered 2 of the white diamond pattern on greyish taupe background ones (shorter version). There's weird lumps %26 bumps of different sizes (feels like debris) under the permanent covering of the product (clearly was manufactured that way). That would be really uncomfortable to potentially painful to stand on w/ bare feet. Plus, some felt like had sharper edges, which physics of standing on them %26 applying pressure could easily result in whatever that is poking through plastic covering. That would damage mats %26 could be safety issue if pokes or cuts bare feet. Also 1 arrived open %26 damaged, because packaging wasn't secure enough. Both mats will be returned %26 we'll be purchasing elsewhere until Sam's Club addresses product safety %26 quality issues w/ whomever is making these mats for Member's Mark now. Really disappointed w/ this version of product.

Helpful?27URMA7BSBEN13585924599
Oct 28, 2023
Stormy
1 out of 5 stars review

Wrong Mat - Disappointed with telephone service

I have ordered this mat twice in gray. I have the same mat in a different size & wanted this to match. Unfortunately - each time I was sent a brown/tan mat. The first time, I first checked that I had ordered the correct color (which I had) so I assumed that the person pulling the order had made a mistake. The second time, having received the same mat, I asked the person at the help desk at my local Sam's club to check why I was being sent the wrong mat. She was extremely helpful & finally said that the number that I had ordered has the tan mat (not the gray mat) listed. She gave me the toll free number to talk with a Sam's club representative to see how/if I could order the gray mat. Today I called the number. It was a very long wait time. I had to explain the situation several times. I was on the line with the initial representative for a long time as she would put me on hold to double check things. Finally she said that she saw the problem but it wasn't something that she could fix. She again put me on hold to speak with her supervisor. I had to again explain the situation to the supervisor who suggested that I order it again & see if I got the right mat. She disagreed with the others who said that the wrong number was associated with the product on line. She said that there was nothing more that could be done; that it could not be guaranteed that I would receive the item that I had ordered & there was nothing to be done to rectivy if. I asked to speak to somebody who could help me rectify the situation & was told that the person who I was speaking to was the "end of the line." On a positive note - return was simple at the store except for the long wait at the service desk both times that I had to return.

Helpful?27URMA7BSBEN13585924599
Mar 1, 2025
Angi
2 out of 5 stars review

Espresso color is NOT as shown, it's RUST

I ordered the Espresso Scroll. It's shown in the photos as a dark brown with scroll. As soon as i opened the package I could see it wasn't what I ordered. Instead of a dark espresso color, it's an ugly rust!! Unfortunately, I have to schlep this back to Sam's for a refund. The reason why I had it delivered with my order is because it's heavy and difficult to lift. I won't be ordering this one online again

Helpful?27URMA7BSBEN13585924599