Let me tell you, when we by pie it's never gone so quickly. We brought this one home to take to a party, next day the whole thing was gone. We then found out who it was we was surprised. It was the most pickiest person in the house. They thought it was home made. Let's just say we had to buy two more pronto that day.

Bought these in the past and they were good quality and value. The last few were undercooked so haven’t bought any in a while. My cousin brought one over last night and it was undercooked. Hard apples and the dough was a disgusting paste. Wish they would solve the problem, can’t believe people are enjoying this.

I bought this pie at Sam’s because I got the pumpkin pie over the holidays and really enjoyed it. But this is the worst apple pie I have ever tasted. It was bland and the dough was gummy and it left a strange metallic taste in my mouth. It isn’t worth driving back to Sam’s to return it so I’ll trash it.

This apple pie tasted more like bananas. The texture of the filling was also strange, it was like apple sauce with chunks of apples. I remember these pies being so good but unfortunately it seems like they made changes and whatever this is now is not appetizing.

What a sad way to end Thanksgiving.. with an apple pie that's still raw and the apples taste way too mushy, how is that even possible?? Overly sugary and just not enjoyable whatsoever. Seems they rushed to cook a bunch of pies and didn't even take the time to be sure it was done right knowing people would be using these for the holiday. What a let down..

Good value for the size, but this pie is too sweet for me. Also, sometimes the crust of these apple pies is under cooked and is doughy and gooey. I've bought one of these pies multiple times and it's hit or miss with the crust being under cooked. If you happen to get one with an under cooked crust, the rating goes down to one star. In addition to being too much added sugar making the pie too sweet, there is also too much cinnamon added and any flavor of the apples is wiped out.

We usually love this pie, but not this year. It looked great when we got it as it was more cooked and brown on top. I always cook it some more to caramelize it, but it didn't want to caramelize as usual. Crust didn't have that good taste as usual and overall, it was not an enjoyable experience eating it.

Hubs brought this home tonight and first, I was surprised how big it is. Second, it tastes fantastic! I love the sugary top; wonder if it's turbinado sugar? The crust is very thick and will actually make up a good portion of your piece but I don't mind. I would 100% recommend this.

I usually order a tiramisu, but they were out of stock last week. I ordered the Apple Pie and it was amazing. For one thing, it's huge. I don't think I've ever bought an apple pie as large as this one. The taste was great- the apples were fresh, the cinnamon was perfect. One of the best apple pies I've ever had!

This pie had wonderful flavor! However, the lattice crust was not completely done It was hit & miss. The apples were still quite crunchy. I prefer my fruit to be soft. However, others in our party found the apples to be delish. It's simply a matter of taste. All in all I would purchase the apple pie again, but making sure to pick one that is quite brown.