These cheese sticks are not a bad deal for the price. The taste is definitely not as good as Sargentos, but you’re not paying a Sargento price. Now for the bad news. The individual wrapping on each stick is terrible. They peel away just fine, but the perforations are not good. They don’t separate from each other very well at all.

I love this Colby cheese! I have purchased it several times in the past. The last 2 times the plastic around the cheese did NOT stay together when peeling. So I had to look for long stringy pieces of plastic on the cheese. Unfortunately I do not have the outer wrap as I opened the package both times and dumped them in the frig. I will most likely try this cheese again but it will be a few months.

Impossible to open without scissors - not good for kids' lunches or taking on hikes. The manufacturer made a token effort with "peel here" instructions on the package, but it is impossible to peel the ends of the package apart. The packaging should support "on the go" school lunches or hiking snacks, but it DOES NOT.

Lower quality than the Sargento we used to be able to get. Sticks are hard to separate which can tear open the cheese next to it. Most of my most recent package have white cakey mold on them even though they are no where near the best by date. Never had that problem with Sargento. Cheese is obviously lower quality and their plant must have sanitation issues. Switching back to buying Sargento or a different house brand in a grocery store

I purchased these and immediately upon leaving tried one as a snack, it tasted off -just disgusting, I then realized there was something black on the cheese stick. I should’ve just returned them then because as soon as I got home I realized HALF the pack had these black spots on them. The ones that didn’t tasted fine. I was so disappointed that I only got half of what I paid for. I wish I could post a picture with this review.

This Member’s Mark Colby cheese is awful. It tastes like plastic and does not have a good flavor. Sam’s Club used to carry Sargento and it is quality and delicious. I have noticed Sam’s Club no longer carries brands that I rely on for quality and will not renew my membership.

Bring back Kraft and other major cheese brands because members mark isn't it. This is terrible quality. Gritty and thick ... unrefined. Just one taste from Sargento and it's obvious. Seems to me you're counting on people to not care because the price is stupid cheap but many of us KNOW what real cheese tastes like. Taking advantage of people who don't know better isn't right and is, quite frankly beneath Sam's Club in my opinion. I keep seeing you guys removing other brands so you can fully run only your brand and that's your choice, you'll just run your quality customers right outta here. Stop this madness. Fire the fool who thought this was a good idea and get it together.

We used to buy Sargentos two packs at a time. Love them because they are so smooth. Sams stopped selling them and is making their own. Definitely not the same. Thank goodness we only bought one pack. It is still sitting in our fridge after a couple of months. Definitely a waste of money. Not smooth like Sargentos at all. We have had to buy the Sargentos brand from the grocery store. It has definitely made our trips to Sams less because sometimes that is all we went for even though we would buy a lot more. Saving us some money so I guess there is a positive for us.

Taste like chemicals

These cheese sticks are billed as a convenient on-the-go snack. I can't get into the individual stick without scissors. If I can't open them easily, they are not "convenient."