Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark American Cheese 5 lbs., 160 slices for
Member's Mark American Cheese 5 lbs., 160 slices
4.7 out of 5 stars
stars3,521 ratings734 reviews
  1. 5 stars82% (2,872)
  2. 4 stars10% (348)
  3. 3 stars5% (169)
  4. 2 stars1% (50)
  5. 1 star2% (82)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 71-80 of 734 reviews
Jul 12, 2024
Paul49
2 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Disappointing Compared to Kraft Singles

I bought this in lieu of Kraft yellow singles, which were out of stock. On the whole, I regret the decision. The Members Mark cheese is tasteless, has a texture the is somewhat reminiscent of so-called "vegan" cheese slices (not to overstate the comparison). This product seems geared for wholesale — higher volume sandwich shops, etc. — not individual consumers, which I am. I will not be buying again.

Helpful?1OEWFOIHH81713578123437
Jul 9, 2024
Camarojeannie
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Family loves this cheese!

Our family loves this cheese. Make great sandwiches, burgers come alive with cheese flavor and the melt factor is great. Pricepoint for the quality is spot on. The cheese block is divided in four sections making it easy to freeze and keep longer. Just bringing out a block at a time to thaw and use.

Helpful?1OEWFOIHH81713578123437
May 14, 2022
Neon spaghetti
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

The best one

My family prefers this American cheese over all the other American cheese options. They are not individually wrapped, but I have found them easy to store in the fridge using 2 freezer zip bags and 1 sandwich zip bag for the cheese we're actively eating. I take one stack out and keep it in the smaller sandwich bag. The rest I put in the freezer bags by turning one inside out so that the seams of the 2 bags can meet in the middle of the rest of the cheese and be sealed together. The taste of this cheese is much better and less salty than name brands.

Helpful?1OEWFOIHH81713578123437
Dec 25, 2024
McConMan
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Great price and makes great sandwiches.

Best price I can find anywhere. Of course it isn't the "real" thing but 99% of what is sold in stores isn't either. If you want the "real" thing then you will pay twice or three times as much and probably have to get it in a deli. But with how much my grandkids eat of this I could not afford that so this is great. It tastes good and makes great cheese sandwiches.

Helpful?1OEWFOIHH81713578123437
Dec 13, 2023
FirstCityEmb
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Makes Impressive Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

Having been a frequent consumer of Kraft's sliced American cheese, I approached this new product with a healthy dose of skepticism, uncertain about its melting capabilities and overall texture. To my surprise, the cheese outperformed my expectations when I used it to make grilled cheese sandwiches. The melting process was notably smoother compared to the Kraft brand, offering a softer and more nuanced taste. The value of this product is commendable, priced at just $9.98 for 160 slices when I purchased it. As I experimented with two slices for my grilled cheese sandwiches, I found that the cheese melted consistently without drying out, making it a promising candidate for crafting delicious cheeseburgers in the future. Beyond sandwiches, this cheese's versatility is apparent when I consider its potential in enhancing the creaminess and cheesiness of a macaroni & cheese meal. In summary, this cheese has managed to surprise and impress, proving itself as a worthy contender to the more established brands in the market. Its value proposition, combined with its melting qualities and subtle flavor, make it a worthwhile addition to my culinary arsenal.

Helpful?1OEWFOIHH81713578123437
Apr 20, 2020
alcon121
4 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

American Cheese

Really liked these, the only reason I gave it a 4 star is because since it is so many slices and they are not individually wrapped any left over cheese starts to dry up and they stick together making it harder later on to pull a slice without tearing others with it.

Helpful?1OEWFOIHH81713578123437
May 9, 2025
Clara
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Awesome cheese for any use.

This is the flavor of cheese that I grew up on. If you like the flavor, it's the cheese to use on whatever you to put cheese on. It's easy to grab a piece from the frig. I take the 4 stacks apart and put a piece of a stack in an airtight container. The rest of the cheese goes into a larger airtight container for storage and preservation. I do share this large chunk of cheese with other siblings and their families.

Helpful?1OEWFOIHH81713578123437
Dec 31, 2024
TJ
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Cheese Slices

These cheese slices are so good and creamy. We will only purchase these from now on. Slices fit perfectly into the small red lid rubbermaid containers. I then put in my deep freezer. When I start getting low in one container I pull out and refrigerator a few days. Taste great and works really good since there is only 2 of us.

Helpful?1OEWFOIHH81713578123437
Feb 21, 2023
janto2
4 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Smaller than last package

This cheese is great! It has so much more flavor than the smaller packaging slices. The only complaint I have is the "shrink". I had twp slices left of the old package. When I added the new cheese to my container, it was about 1/4-inch all arond smaller. BTW, we always buy this cheese. It lasts forever when properly wrapped. We keep about 1/3 package in the kitchen in a plastic (food safe) container.

Helpful?1OEWFOIHH81713578123437
Nov 19, 2024
Cat M
2 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Tastes ok, slices are small

I usually buy the 5 lb 120 slice package of American cheese, which has regular sized slices of cheese, however it seems to suddenly be no longer available. These cheese slices in the 5 lb 160 slice count package are simply too small. The slices don't even cover pieces of regular sliced bread.

Helpful?1OEWFOIHH81713578123437