This pumpkin pie was a disappointment. Maybe it was just me. No one else thought less of it. It also seems led a bit thin in the pie crust.

This pie tasted great and the value was exceptional. I don't think I will make another pumpkin pie again

This pumpkin pie was delicious and we had leftovers which we sliced and froze for future enjoyment! It was such an excellent price too!

Huge pie that is very flavorful. I prefer a thicker crust, but at this price, you get what you pay for! Good deal !

Totally delicious pumpkin pie! Not too sweet, not over-spiced, silky mouth feel, excellent for a 8 person gathering with a little left over.

First time I bought the pumpkin pie 🥧 and it actually tasted like homemade. I ended up getting another one a few weeks later.

I usually buy a frozen pie for Thanksgiving, this year was different. I got a fresh pie, it tasted so good. Will buy a fresh pumpkin pie from now on.

Great pumpkin pie! I didnt have the time to make them homemade this year for Thanksgiving, and everyone loved it! Great price too!

There is something about Sam's Club pies that I don't care for. Too cinnamony, thick crust, just not my cup of tea.

One of the best pumpkin pies we ever had, plus generous size. We have tried similar pies from Publix and Winn-Dixie, no comparison to Sam’s.