My family was so disappointed with this pie. There wasn't one of us that liked it and my husband eats everything. The pie had a weird texture and a overly strong spice taste. The crust was hard and not flaky at all. Sam's use to have one of the best pumpkin pies but not anymore. I wish Sam's would bring back the old recipe!

My family and I look forward to this seasonal favorite every year and this year it was a huge disappointment. Consistency and taste was off. I brought one in to work (where nothing ever goes to waste) and only a couple pieces were eaten and the comments were that it tastes weird.

I love pumpkin pie, and I have always loved the one from Sam's club. I picked one up tonight and was so disappointed. It is horrible. The crust is so hard, I can barely break through it with my fork. And the flavoring of the filling is horrible. I am so glad I tried this before taking it to my mother's on Thanksgiving as usual. This will not be purchased again, and this will definitely not be a Thanksgiving dessert. Such a dissappointment. Why change a good thing???

Really gone down hill from previous years. The pumpkin is very light in color, and the taste is just so so. Not the good pumpkin you used to have in your pies. What has changed? Almost tastes and looks like it has fillers in it to make it stretch further. Hmmm

Closest pumpkin pie to my moms homemade that I've ever had.

Awesome pie and great value!

Not good taste. Definitely disappointed ☹️

Very good pumpkin pie…. Don’t forget the whipped cream !

Wow! As good as my homemade!

Never again. It taste nasty not really bold in the pumpkin flavor