I feel like they changed the recipe they normally use, or maybe I just got an old or bad pie but this year it was really off the mark. My family and I each only had one slice (which we each didn’t finish) and then it was avoided til it was tossed

This pie was excellent! The filling had the perfect amount of spice. The crust was crispy and not mushy. I was impressed and can’t wait to get another one! One of the best. For the money it was a great deal!

The size is perfect for large gatherings. I did find the pumpkin pie to be sweeter than homemade and lacked some of the pumpkin taste. It’s ok, but next time I’ll make time to make one from scratch.

Sams has the best bakery, and the pumpkin pie is a seasonal favorite in our house. We have tried them at other warehouse stores and grocery stores and these are the best. The crust is great, which makes the pie!

Not so good I've baught pp from Sam's every holiday, and just because they're good. But this one i bought didn't have any flavor it was BLAND couldn't taste the pumpkin, NOT GOOD also dry.

Almost like homemade, but without all the work. I like to cut a thin slice and just eat it from my hand, like a good slice of pizza. Sweet, but not too sweet and the texture is nice too.

Sam's Club always make my pies for me, will you? Your pumpkin pies make my every holiday and I even take them to other celebrations/functions. They are always a hit with everyone! So delicious! They may be store bought but they taste homemade. Wonderful!

These are the best pumpkin pies for Thanksgiving and or Xmas. You just need to get them early or they will be all gone. Sams just needs to order more for this time of year. They taste great and are the crust is just done right. I always look for these for the Holidays to have or bring to a guest hosting a holiday dinner.

For as many years as Sam’s Club has been in business, my family has been eaten this pumpkin pie to the exclusion of any other bakery’s pie. This pie is bigger than anyone else pie so it will feed the entire Thanksgiving guest list. And I always have to mention the pocketbook, my costs are always uppermost in my mind. You can buy this pie, you won’t be sorry!

My wife used to bake our pumpkin pies but since we sampled Sam's pumpkin pie in 2022 we always buy Sam's now. They taste great. During the season we buy extra for the whole year and keep them in the freezer to enjoy them all year. Please do not change the recipe.