I bought this for our Shepherd's lunch at church. It went over well. I had a bit left to share with my daughter and a piece for moi! Excellent pie, rivals my grandmother's, and she made the very best. She always saved me a little cup of mixture before she baked the pies. She never baked 1 pie it was always 10 or 12!! Great memories. Your pie is excellent!!

Yuck! Member's Mark Pumpkin Pie has always been a fall favorite, but this year they changed it. Its made by a different bakery, smaller, and has a strange aftertaste. The pie has never lasted more than a few hours. A quarter of this one went in the trash four days after I bought it. Other's I know had the same experience.

Too big of diameter. Makes for long skinny pieces unless you cut it for samples like Sam's.

Normally the pumpkin pies are very tasty and a great value. I’ve bought them for several years. This time however, I was very disappointed. The pie filling was less firm than usual and the crust was very soggy, to the point that I didn’t want to eat it. This was an exception. Normally the pies are perfect.

We have enjoyed Sam's Club's pumpkin pie for holiday seasion for years. This year however they seemed to change the recipie. The flavor and texture was not the same, it didn't have as much pimpkin flavor as before. We were quite disapointed. Outers have mentioned to us the same observation.

Great deal. Great pie! You probably could not buy the ingredients and make it yourself for the sale price.

We always look forward to pumpkin pie at Sam’s Club. Great value for the size. Almost don’t want to share. Yum!!

We enjoyed eating this pie; however, it is not as tasty as others we have tried. Probably will not purchase again.

The best for our Thanksgiving dinner

The pie was very good.. good price ,, but expiration was too soon