I have been buying Sam’s Club pumpkin pie for years. This did not taste as good this year as I remember it being, but it’s still better than our local grocery store.

Love this pie, just wish they would back off the sugar a bit. Great texture and flavor. Absolutely perfect when you heat it up as it browns the bottom crust perfectly making it almost as good as homemade!

I bought this as a test this year. It was lacking in flavor. A couple of years ago I bought one - it was like the lid came off and the cloves dumped in. Not this year - it was lack luster with not a lot of flavor. Back to baking!

Sam's Club home made pumpkin pie is the best, absolutely delicious! The pumpkin pie reminds me of the pumpkin pie mom bakes for the holidays! And the cost is very affordable, a great value!!

The pumpkin and apple pies were absolutely delicious. Fresh and not overly sweet. Just perfect and my friends and family raved about how they couldn’t stop eating the apple pie. Will definitely buy again!!

This pie was good but the first one I bought this season was much better. This one had slightly soggy crust, disappointing after the first one being so good but still more convenient than baking one.

Absolutely love this pie. Tastes great & my kids always get excited when I bring one home, as it’s a staple at Thanksgiving time (or anytime during the holidays). Can’t beat the price for the amount of servings you get!

I love this pumpkin pie, I’m always excited when the holidays arrive. I typically place in oven for about 15 minutes because a prefer a darker crust. The filling reminds me of my grandpa’s pies. Brings back sweet memories of holidays past.

It was okay. There was too much spice for me, but it was all gone by the next day… don’t know that I would buy again unless I was taking it somewhere.

Pie was tasty, fresh and packaged great for traveling a few hours by car. For us, the crust was too "doughy", it wasn't flakey, crumbly or crisp. That was a bummer.