The new recipe is kinda mealy. No where near the amount of Pumpkin Spice as the previous recipe. It reminds me of jar baby food.

Little flavor. Filling was fluffy like it had been whipped. Crust was thick and dry with no flavor. Will not buy again.

First time trying Sam's pumpkin and it's very moist, perfect amount of sweetness and price is outstanding!

No wonder this was only $5. It tastes terrible; almost like there's too much salt in it. It's also waaaayyy undercooked!

This pumpkin pie tastes just like Mom and Grandma used to make. It’s the best store bought pie I have ever eaten!

... sometimes not. Great price, but they just don't taste great. They are OK, but I'd rather get a frozen take and bake.

I love pumpkin and sugar. I do a lot of baking and love baked goods. We got this and served it. I took a step back and went and checked the label. My husband did, too. This just tastes super sweet and without pumpkin flavor. Terrible!

One of the worst pumpkin pies I have ever had. Buy a your own risk! Very bad recipe, flavor was bad beyon description. Gave it 1 star only because they don’t have a zero star rating.

Nice large tasty rich thick pumpkin pie, you can feed twelve people!

I don’t know if the pie we got just wasn’t good. But it tasted rancid and just straight up bad:(