New recipe is disgusting. Texture is horrible - straight up mush. Far too bright orange for a moment I though it was raw and needed to be cooked still. Flavor is off. Returning.

We feel this is the best of all times pumpkin pie!!! The crust is Alexa’s perfect, tasty and the pumpkin filling is so delicious!!! I can taste each seasoning equally.

They are finally using a new recipe this season. It's much better than what they were selling for the past five years. The taste and consistency of the filling and crust in this new recipe is perfect.

This pumpkin pie is wonderful. I would love it to be a little more spicy, but most store bought pumpkin pies are not spicy, and for the price point, I'm happy with it. It serves a lot of people. Even a small sliver is enough to make you feel happy, because the pie is so large. I added a little whipped cream with cinnamon sprinkled over the top, and it was great. Thanks Sam's Club.

I purchased this Pumpkin pie for the first time for Thanksgiving 2024 and to my surprise it was DELICIOUS. Everyone that I shared it with enjoyed it and wanted to know where I got it from. I am purchasing another one for Christmas to enjoy. I have told others about it. Try it!

I am very picky about my pumpkin pie. It's not as good as homemade but I would buy it again. The only thing that prevented 5 stars is the thickness of the crust. It could be about 1/2 as thick and be perfect. I want to buy another one but it's out of stock.

I baked Pumpkin pies before - 75 in one holiday season. The pie filling was just ok, but the thick pie crust was difficult to cut, even harder to eat, and lacked taste. I would not buy again - rather make my own with a soft tasty thinner flakey style crust.

This was our first year trying this pumpkin pie. It was very good!! The spices were just right, the consistency was perfect! The crust is very thick, but tasty, it wasn't soggy. I would definitely buy this again. I was a bit hesitant to buy it based on some of the previous reviews. I was so thankful the pie was good!

We purchased the pie 5 days ago and refrigerated it for Thanksgiving. I was skeptical because this is a big pie and the price is so reasonable. To our surprise, the pie is delicious. It is easy to cut and plate. The texture is creamy, not too sweet, and the amount of spices was just right. Great pie for a family gathering.

We bought 2. Cutting into the first.. The crust was hard and thick. The filling was gelled. We thought that maybe we misunderstood, so we read and reread the labels the see if there was cooking instructions. None. We put the second in the oven for twenty minutes @ 350. Much better, but not great. We expected better from Sam's.