New recipe is horrible. Crust is too thick and tasted kind of stale. I'll just stick with their competitors pumpkin pie.

I haven't bought one of these pies in years. The last time I did purchase one, I didn't care for it. I decided for $6 I would give it another shot. It was so good! I was pleasantly surprised. I will definitely be buying more!

Usually make my own but a lady at the store said these were the best pies. The filling is pretty good but the crust is lousy, way too thick and no flavor. I think all of them use the same crust recipe.

I bought one of these pumpkin pies last week because the price was right! I'm glad I did! The flavor was perfect! Delicious!! I'm not really a pumpkin pie fan usually; but, I sure did enjoy this one! Will definitely go back for more!!

By far Sam’s Pumpkin Pie is the closest to homemaker of any store bought pumpkin pie we’ve had. This pie is huge and still unbelievably priced lower than other store bought pies.

This is the best pumpkin pie ever!I plan on whipping some heavy cream with cream cheese and some powdered sugar and spread on the top for Thanksgiving.Yum!

Very tasty pie at a great price!! Would definitely recommend. My son loves these!! Wish they were available all the time as they are a go-to food for my autistic child.

As other reviews have mentioned, there is too much pumpkin pie spice in the pie. I personally find pumpkin pie abhorrent but my wife loves it. She used to love the old recipe. This new one is not as good.

This is the best store bought pumpkin pie I have ever ate. It tastes as good as the homemade pies my mother use to make.(using fresh cooked pumpkin & homemade pie crust)It is even great ice cold with whipped cream

Bland City.