We tasted a sample pie being given out to customers at the store which was quite good in taste and texture almost as good as home made; HOWEVER when we took our pie home it did not have the same flavor or texture and hardly anyone had more than a bite before we had to discard it in the trash. Not sure what happened, the store pies are usually very good - Apple, Cherry and Pumpkin our favorites of the family.

I don't know what people expect from a store made pie. Read some of the negative reviews and think those people would not be happy with a pie made from fresh pumpkin. I have been purchasing these for years when that a available. NEVER have we gotten a pie the did not get devoured. You will not hear complaints from my family.

Our Member’s Mark pumpkin pie for Thanksgiving was soooo good! We keep it cool in the garage, and that works well for us, plus saves space in the refrigerator. As we served dinner, the pie was sitting out on the counter, and everyone kept staring at it in anticipation for dessert. The pie filling was firm and tasty, the crust was light and flaky. And the pie pan and cover are the best. Sam’s Club is our go-to for bakery products. We’ve never been disappointed.

Better than last year! We have enjoyed Sam’s pumpkin pies for years, but the pumpkin pie last season was awful. We tried it twice and ugh. Super strong….like too much nutmeg maybe??? I was hoping it was just a temporary thing and thankfully it was. This time the pie was great! Back how it has always been…Just the right amount of spices. Will be buying several more. Such an excellent value! Please stick with this original recipe. :)

You can't make this pie from scratch for this price! I take a circular cookie cutter and cut this into mini round pieces then I add a squirt of whipped cream on top. It looks super pretty, its just enough of a sweet treat and it tastes great. People rave over the taste and appearance.

My wife used to bake our pumpkin pies but since we sampled Sam's pumpkin pie in 2022 we always buy Sam's now. They taste great. During the season we buy extra for the whole year and keep them in the freezer to enjoy them all year. Please do not change the recipe.

The pie was extra large and had good presentation. Not sure of the taste but assume it was delicious since the dog ate the entire pie. The reason I gave it four stars instead of five is it caused extreme diarrhea and vomiting in the dog. The one piece that was served to a human, said the pie was good and did not cause any ill effects

It was delicious, the last one in the store and it was great! Someone else from curbside pick up didn't want it because a piece of crust about 2” was broke. It turned out great and made us very happy. Plus the curbside lady was amazing. There was a lady that wasn't fluent in English helping me and her co-worker stepped in and helped because my rotisserie chickens were still cooking I ran in for pie and got lucky!

This is a very good value for a large size pumpkin pie. It was under $6 dollars when I purchased it. It is creamy and tasty and very filling. I would suggest adding some whipped cream topping on it when you eat it. It keeps fairly well outside of the refrigerator as long as you keep it sealed in its container between feasting.

For me, this pumpkin pie tastes just right. Perfect balance of spices that does not overpower the pumpkin. The filling is the right consistency. And the price is unbeatable. It's just not worth buying any other, or making your own, when this is available to you!