Large and tasty with tender pie crust. My family loves this inexpensive dessert and big enough for generous sized cuts. A little bland but not everyone likes a stronger spiced pumpkin filling

These pies are my absolute favorite. I recently purchased one for a family get together and it was terrible. The texture was off and the taste was so bland!

I have always loved Sam's Club baked goods. I got one recently and the pumpkin would not stay on the crust, and you could not cut the crust. The worst

Purchased Oct. 9, 2025. We always liked Sam's pumpkin pie, but this year it's lacking the spices. Not very good. I was going to buy for our Thanksgiving dinner this year, but will make my own.

Best pumpkin pie that I have found. Very tasty and it is hugh. Probably twice the size of most pies and only $5.99. 8 good sized portions or 16 small ones.

Taste, smell, look, perfectly spiced, and feel of an authentic homemade pie. If you have no self control, then don't buy it. Because you might just eat the entire pie.

Absolutely delicious pumpkin pie with a great flavor that is creamy with a perfect blend of spices. It's huge and is great value. Will be buying this every year.

Did not last long enough enough. I only got one piece, my son had eaten all the rest by the day after I brought it home. He left me one smaller piece!

Normally Sams Club pumpkin pies are very good, this time around, terrible, bad taste and the texture was grainy. Would not recommend, will seek an alternate next time.

This pumpkin pie was not good at all. It was too sweet and little flavor. The crust was thick, doughy and no flavor at all. Do not care for pumpkin pies made with granulated sugar. Brown sugar for me, like my Mom made and more spice.