My wife wanted a pumpkin pie. So I got her one! She said it "sucked!" It tasted funny and was way to sweet!

Returned, lacked any pumpkin flavor, it is like they forgot to add normal pumpkin pie spices or any spice at all this year.

Purchased Oct. 9, 2025. We always liked Sam's pumpkin pie, but this year it's lacking the spices. Not very good. I was going to buy for our Thanksgiving dinner this year, but will make my own.

This pumpkin pie was not good at all. It was too sweet and little flavor. The crust was thick, doughy and no flavor at all. Do not care for pumpkin pies made with granulated sugar. Brown sugar for me, like my Mom made and more spice.

I did not like that. it said this is baked fresh daily in the store and when I ordered it for same-day delivery it arrived to my house Frozen as in too hard to eat Frozen. obviously this is not a fresh baked pie.

I have always loved Sam's Club baked goods. I got one recently and the pumpkin would not stay on the crust, and you could not cut the crust. The worst

These pies are my absolute favorite. I recently purchased one for a family get together and it was terrible. The texture was off and the taste was so bland!

Absolutely delicious pumpkin pie with a great flavor that is creamy with a perfect blend of spices. It's huge and is great value. Will be buying this every year.

Normally Sams Club pumpkin pies are very good, this time around, terrible, bad taste and the texture was grainy. Would not recommend, will seek an alternate next time.

Thought it was ok until í ate half , stomach started bothering me, got a bump on my back. This has "Bio Engineered " which another term for GMO, LABELS NEED TO NOTE THIS FIRST AND IN THE INGREDIENTS LIST.